
Will I honestly make it one violin? Probably not, I suck, I really do. I'll never be as good as I want to be, as good as I should be considering I want it to be the rest of my life. Can I honestly expect to get a job? No, because I won't be good enough either for teaching or playing professionally. You have to audition for every position, I could be an excelllent teacher and not get the job because I wouldn't put on a good enough recital every year. I'm not evening being pessimistic here, I'm being realistic. I'm just not good enough at music, end of story. I started violin late, I started lessons late, I started caring late, I did just about everything wrong on the path to be an excellent violinist. I could of course be a mediocre violinist, there are many of those, and most of those end up working at McDonalds for the rest of their lives. Do I honestly want my life to have a mediocre existance? Actually, I don't think I have a lot of choice in the matter, I'm just a mediocre person, I guess I come a dime a dozen. I'm a 2nd violinist, I let my nerves get the best of me, I can't play with piano and I can't play piano, I'm bad with people, I'm bad a being alone, I never made it into All-State Orchestra, I give up too easily (Concertmaster Audition), I'm obviously not as good academically as I thought I was, I'm somewhat arrogant (I have no reason to be, I'm not good at anything, obviously!!), and finally, I want to do things that I'm bad at. In conclusion, what the heck am I doing!!!
I am serious about what I'm about to say: If I'm not at Luther after this summer it could be for three reasons 1) I decided to stay permanently on as a staff member at the Pennitentury (they tend to draw you in I've heard, my dad was going to work their for 6 months, it's now been over 26 years and he's a corporal working for Special Security) or 2) I was convicted of a Class 6 felony because I was conned by an inmate into bringing contraband (tabacoo, drugs, hacksaw blades, weapons, alcohol etc.) into the prison and I will be serving my sentence there or 3) I decided it's not worth going there if I decide that I suck at violin too much to continue in music.
Night
If you love it, don't give it up! What's wrong with being a 2nd? If music was all melody (1sts) it would be boring. I personally prefer playing 2nd because I love harmony (and I can count). *Not that 1sts can't count, it's just really important for 2nds (I don't want to offend anyone!)*
Most importantly, don't let the frustration of your grades now make you make a rash decision you will regret later. Take some time to make a big decision like this.
Finally, if you do decide to change your major, find ways you can still play. Community orchestras can be loads of fun and are filled with teachers, doctors, burger-flippers, construction workers, accountants, and all sorts of others that love making music, but not for a living.
Chin up...and then back down on your violin ;) !!!
Mellisa
While being self-critical can be extremely useful in teh practice room (which it seems like you can be, which is a GOOD thing) it can kill you outside of it. It's so easy to think of "what if" scenarios... believe me, I used to do it all the time ("What if I had started earlier?" "What if I had gotten a teacher before high school?" "What if I had just practiced really really hard beforehand?").
As nontheistic as I try to be, I truely think that everything does happen for a reason, and that this is just a test for you right now. You can either allow the self-doubt to destroy your passion and hard work towards something you truely love, or you can push past it and do your absolute best from now on. The choice is yours. The main question is: How much do you love it?
I could not agree more!!
This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine