I'm thinking about changing from Dominant to Jargar violin strings. I've been playing Dominants for about two years now but just can't get used to them. The G string in particular sounds too coarse and brash. I play a Paesold 807 GG built in 2004.
My problem is that I cannot find any reviews of Jargar violin strings as a set. There are many plaudits though for the E string in relation to G, D and A strings of other makers.
The deafening silence bothers me. Am I missing something ?
Any pointers gratefully received...
Cheers
John Savage
Just wondering:
If your G is too coarse and brash, why would you expect a skis steel core string to improve that?
Obligatos are often recommended for toning down a bright instrument. Or a cheaper route may be to try Corelli Crystals.
Or perhaps what's really needed is a luthier to look at your soundpost ?
Is your Dominant G really too coarse and brash? Have you checked what it sounds like at a distance?
I went through the Associated Board grades and scraped through the '60s ALCM (Mozart 5 1st movement for first piece) using steel strings like Jargar, but a few weeks before performing the first two movements of the Brahms D minor I changed to high quality gut (Eudoxa, then, mistakenly for my violin, Golden Spiral), because the tone was richer and the sensitivity of the response more satisfactory for what I thought my abilities had become (They're not like that now, I'm afraid, and some Dominants, which came in since then, are mounted, but going back to steel would be an admission that my lack of bow control has become so serious that covering up for it is more important than giving myself a good expressive range).
In your case, if you have the expressive abilities of a Grapelli, I would say avoid steel like the plague (I gather Tertis Model violas are an exception), but if you're a real "scratcher", then maybe Jargar are for you. If the case is somewhere in between, I'd stick to synthetics, but you could try Aricore - I think it was Arthur Grove who told me they were milder than Dominant.
Thank you all for responding to my message.
You have given me food for thought. I don't think I'll go for the Jargars. My local luthier knows my fiddle and tells me that the setup is fine. Following the response from John Rokos, I've decided that I'm somewhere between 'Grappelli and Scratcher'. It looks as though it's a choice between Corelli and Obligato (£££) - funds permitting.
Cheers
John Savage
The Corelli Cantiga G has been praised as well, and that's an affordable set.
Before Perlon appeared, I used Eudoxa for classical music, and Spirocore or Jargar for tangos in a noisy environment. Spirocore need their little rubber ring to filter ot the "buzz" at th start of each note; Jargars have a rounder tone.
But both are very high tension, more than Evahs or Helicores, and they suffocate a responsive instrument.
Good for masking clumsy bowing, though..
Jargars are popular with cellists, as are other steel strings. I have a suspicion that steel strings generally work better on that larger instrument than they do on the violin. In fact, my cello is strung with heavy gauge Helicores which seem to last forever, an important consideration given the cost of cello strings.
I use Jargar E strings, they've served me well for the past 4 years
I use a Jargar G, D and E with a Russian Style A from Warchal and it really brings a lot of depth out of my instrument, which has a generally dark sound anyway. The A provides a nice bridge between the kind of brassy E string and deep, rich lower register. :-)
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Elmar Oliveira International Violin Competition
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
October 14, 2014 at 11:26 PM · They're steel strings, and are stiffer and probably usually less resonant and colorful than most classical violin players like for the A, D, and G.