I've seen a lot of "colorful" violins advertised and wondered if anyone had one and does the color used on the violin have any effect on sound? Do they have to put on several layers of color? I'm talking about the ones that are ,I guess, "painted" purple and blue and so on...just curious. :)
Yes, any paint on the violin will affect the sound. I noticed that when I was playing guitar the type of finish would change the sound even on a solid body electric instrument. The changes would be even more obvious on an acoustic instrument like the violin.
As has been pointed out, these coloured violins are usually the worst violins you could possibly buy...stay away !
THEY ARE BAD! besides the instrument being poorly made, with cheap wood, but remember with a violin that the wood vibrates. Imagine if a someone painted a drum head purple. The paint prevents the instrument to vibrate correctly.
ALL violins have several layers of stains and varnishes on them. A blue or purple stain won't do anything to the wood that a brown, gold, or red stain wouldn't do as well. (I've never looked at one of these instruments up close, but I have little doubt that the color comes from a stain and not paint.) If the sound is awful, don't blame the color.
I haven't seen any that uses colored varnish. They are all painted with... well... paint.
From working in a music store, and as a teacher in schools I have seen quite a few of these colored instruments. Non of them are of good quality, they are bad instruments coated in paint, and every student who had one became more discouraged playing it in the end.
People will often call opaque finishes "paint" and transparent ones "varnish" but in fact there can be little difference between them. Any violin varnish can be made to be opaque rather easily and in any color desired. It's much more difficult to make transparent colored varnishes that will allow the wood's grain to be seen.
This is not to say that a purple ebay violin is going to be something worth playing, but that a good violinmaker could make a purple violin that would sound equal to a traditionally colored one. Cheers,
One thing about a solid color finish; it can be used to mask bad wood, patches, filler, etc.I'll bet you could even use plywood!
Good to know! And I was reading a description of a violin for sale online and it said it was made of "pressed wood". So I know there are probably some "violins" out there that are just eye candy and not playable. :) I'll stick to handmade.
I used to have a painted violin. It was terrible. Its story is interesting though.
It was a day before my birthday and I was riding in a cab, heading to my violin class. My teacher had temporarily given his extremely amazing violin to me. It was made in Czech and its size was 7/8 which was quite rare. Anyway, I got out of the cab and realized that I had left the violin in it...
I told my teacher about it and since he was really pissed at me he gave me this green, sparkly violin and said: Here's your birthday present!
The violin pretty much sucked. It didn't even look like a violin... I just can't describe how terrible it was!
I just kept it for a week...
Here's a link to a green varnish - just to look at.
I don't like it myself...but it does show off the wood grain...
http://www.fiddleheads.ca/shop/violin_photos/new/chinese/aurora/green_2011-1.htm
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
June 27, 2012 at 05:03 AM · I don't know whether the colour changes the sound at all but these violins are the worst kind of cheap VSO. I expect all the colours will sound as bad as each other including the varnished violins in the range.
For a little more money, one can directly import, a much better violin directly from China. Look up Yitamusic on this site's search engine.
Cheers Carlo