Don't let it get to you -- it won't last. If you're confident of your abilities and doing well with the instrument, that's what really matters.
Kids your age are just mean, plain and simple. Best way to cope is to focus on refining your craft until your peers are a bit older, at which point it will start benefiting you to be the person who showed strength and maturity rather than the one who wasted all his time worrying about what other people thought of him.
Oh, and boys are generally the meanest when you're accomplishing something while they do nothing with themselves. It's simple jealousy. So if they're making fun of you, it probably means that you're doing well.
Also, learn how to fight. Watch YouTube boxing videos (don't worry about kicks, they're not really necessary in most situations). Ideally you won't have to, but if you start sticking up for yourself verbally, chances are that they will physically challenge you at some point. And if that happens, it's good to feel confident that you could defend yourself.
As they are more likely to be a mob than just one single boy, you should try to avoid fighting with them verbally or physically, for as much as you can. Just ignore them. Try not to show any attitude or aggression, but don't show you are afraid of them either.
Do communicate with your teachers and parents if they ever reveal the intention of any physical challenge.
P/S women are amazing - I don't mind being compared to one. Same for that other group. Stay strong and shrug it off mate :))
That's what I've done since 9th grade - that was 67 years ago. I played violin in school orchestra and baritone horn (euphonium) in a great 100 piece marching and concert band (those were the days). If you really want to get respect also learn to play the tuba (instead of the baritone) and you can just drop it on those people when the give you guff-but maybe that would be too much effort for a bit of revenge.
Whatever Erik says, don't fight. I haven't had a fight since 7th grade - it can get too dangerous in too many ways as you get older and bigger. Besides boxing practice will make your arms shake so that you can't play the violin - or even write your homework.
These insults are based on demeaning other people as well as comparing you to something they consider to be inferior (women and homosexuals).
They are only insults if you agree that it's bad to be gay and that there is something wrong with being a girl.
As has already been mentioned, these sort of insults come from a place of insecurity. Don't let their insecurity become your insecurity. The greatest harm that we as a society do to our children is to force them into a 'man box' or 'woman box' with defined and set traits.
Be proud to be compared to girls, it's not an insult at all.
And have a Joyous Holiday!!
It might be pretty darned amusing to see how your detractors react. :-)
And so what if you were gay? So were Tchaikovsky, Leonard Bernstein, and Samuel Barber. And Leonardo Da Vinci. And Alan Turing... These men made profound contributions to humanity by being themselves, but some also suffered at the hands of bigots. Here's hoping that your generation can make the world a more enlightened place!
Such language is acceptable in the highest places here, unfortunately.
Sadly some women are the ones still perpetuating it.
It is not uncommon to hear women themselves (especially of non-Western backgrounds) commenting on a guy, "He behaves like a woman", "such a pussy", "Stop being a woman", "Stop ensconcing under my dress", "Be a man".
SMH.
Jason wrote, "And so what if you were gay? So were Tchaikovsky, Leonard Bernstein, and Samuel Barber. And Leonardo Da Vinci. And Alan Turing These men made profound contributions to humanity by being themselves, but some also suffered at the hands of bigots." Those were the ones who were OPENLY gay, or who were outed against their will. The larger population was probably in the closet, since coming out could mean the end of their careers. There have been quite a bit of rumors surrounding other noted scientific/public figures. Isaac Newton, Wright brothers, Ibraham Lincoln, to name a few.
Of course I don't think men are evil, and nobody else has taken it that way.
This post is proof that it's ingrained in children, in western countries, by the age of 13. It's subtle but it's there. "We are in ___" doesn't mean anything.
You have responded in the typical defensive way without any evidence of research, education, or an attempt at empathy.
I feel this has gotten too far off the subject of violin, and will not be making further comment.
Jessy
Our judo instructor was the school's art teacher when he wasn't on the tatami and was the first and only judo black belt in the UK's West Country for many years. It was noticeable that other boys never messed with members of the judo club! Our instructor liked to tell us that the best defence was a 4-minute mile down the road, but this was never mentioned outside the club!
I was 15 when I started playing, but I was lucky and never had any problems.
Now serioysly though, why do you mind about such comments? Give 3 years and they will be green of envy
So you have to find your way and also protect your niche. It takes some time before the violin sounds good and people like to listen, but don’t give up. First, play for yourself, just enjoy your development and achievement. Get a good, friendly, experienced music teacher. Later, join a local orchestra with likeminded people that respect you, because you share the same passion with them. Performing music together is a very strong connection.
As a violinist, even amateur, you can be proud of playing one of the most difficult instruments, can read an additional „language“ (=music score) and demonstrate discipline with practicing, that has proven positive impacts on the brain and intelligence.
Read biographies of extraordinary people (scientiest, entrepreneurs, composers). Most had a difficult time but did their stuff and where successful.. it only made them stronger! What and where would human mankind be without extraordinary people who climbed the unusual path! What would human mankind be without music and arts (music is everywhere)
The return will come, sooner or later! It is your personal way and not the way the others want you to go.. If you enjoy music than you have to continue and the music will give it back to you and guide your way.
Don’t let your playing judge from somebody who has no experience with music or is at least able to read music and play an instrument. Only accept a judgement from somebody who already went the same way.
There are lots of male violinists, look at all the big and famous orchestras, violin professors, solo violinists that earn millions of dollars with concerts.
I wish you, that you find your way with supporting people and keep enjoying the music! The reward will come for sure! the world needs passionate, giving and caring people! Don’t let your voice be lost! the world needs YOUR music!
Julia
P.S. Print all the comments (of this great forum with great caring people that share your way) on paper and put it in your violin case or somewhere and read it from time to time, to remind you to follow your own way and dream.
There is literally nothing to combat. They're wrong, and are expressing their own ignorance, or perhaps saying things just to tease you, which only works when you take it seriously as if it's about you instead of them.
Not very long ago, certainly in some places, all or most violinists used to be men. We're better now when we don't limit activities by gender when they have nothing to do with gender, and have women and men equally playing violin, as they choose.
So, let them go dig their own hole, and you keep playing the violin and improving yourself!
Do we really need to combat one or two prejudices (homophobia, sexism) by exhibiting and propogating others (so far, one classsist and the other racist)?
But THAT should be a reason why a straight man feels the need to be close to it. I hope the OP would stay strong in his pursuits.
I'll never forget that comment and the almost accusatory tone in which he said it. But I don't remember it because I felt insulted--I was probably more independent and self-assured at that age than most. I didn't feel insulted because I recognized it as nonsensical.
The interesting thing about being a string player is that, of all the orchestral instruments, it takes the highest level of innate aggression. Think about other instruments: you can't shred on a flute, harp, or bassoon. Yes, brass are loud, but not in that aggressive way that violins are. I noticed that there seems to be a correlation between violinists and tennis players. Both require a killer instinct.
American males have their own unique ideas about what constitutes masculinity. Manly men drive pickup trucks. Can you imagine a contractor showing up in a mini van? Guns are another totem of American macho culture, which I think helps explain the resistance to gun control: it's not taking away protection or 2nd amendment rights--it's taking alway someone's masculinity. I took my kids to a Halloween pumpkin patch and saw another dad with a 45 strapped to his leg. Because he feared attack? I doubt it. More likely a show of his manliness.
The association of violin with not-manliness is just simply part of American culture, but it hasn't always been around. I suspect it has more to do with percerceptions and resentments of class than sexuality.
At one summer camp, I was labeled "the brain", and the label wasn't intended to be in any way complementary!
There's an axiom: "Be nice to the nerds, because you'll probably be employed by one someday."
Perhaps that will give you enough perspective and hope to get you through this temporary crisis. Yes, it is temporary.
Who says violins are just for girls now? :v)
How is playing the violin a girl thing?
I understand the stereotype for example of ballet is for girls, it makes sense for an 8th grader (don't go crazy on me, I understand it, not share or agree). But playing the violin a girly thing?
I've also never faced someone in school or high school that said playing violin was gay.
In school of course there were bullies in my class, but actually playing an instrument was indeed considered something cool. There were three guitarist, an oboist, a clarinetist and a flautist. I actually played the recorder, for unknown reasons, way better than most of my classmates, and I only received positive experiences, none of them bullies would say that I was gay for playing the recorder that well, indeed once one of the "cool guys" asked me if I could play the Star Wars theme, 8-9th grade.
I didn't say that. What I meant was that people who play the violin can't (regardless of gender) reassumed to be weak or passive.
To clarify, I didn't take that seriously or anything, I was just wondering what you meant by that (obviously it comes from somewhere).
Actually, the situation described in the topic is very common. This boy is just unlucky to be in a average school, where 99,9% never attend any symphony or chamber concert. Or even piano.
And it is partly musicians fault. Rep, pop, etc come to children, to their brains (via tv, radio, shows), but classical musicians expect that children will come to them to a dark hall in the other city 2h of driving away. No propaganda, no PR, no cool shows on tv, no performance in local schools.
This problem was always there. Remember the "They shall have music"? It starts that the father does not understand what violin is for, and got angry on his son for a wish to play it! It reflects the problem, which is there, and only all together musicians can soften the border between them and rest of the word and make this profession more respectful by non musicians.
For Harrison: you can ask your teacher to allocate some time for violin history and culture. You can prepare a presentation on the most impressive episodes from youtube, say some words about its history, let your friends try, and for Friday movie night suggest a good film about violin player.
Have a nice vacation.
They're envious, so don't listen to them. If you like it, go ahead, have fun and enjoy it!
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Miroirs CA Classical Music Journal
Coltman Chamber Music Competition
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
These people are jealous I think, for something with high level of efficiency and professionality. But asi in the other situations, with these idiots, ignore them, it is their stupidity to be such a fools and limited.
P.S. When I see boy playing violin I see the power, and geniality. When I see woman playing violin it is very very attractive to me.
P.P.S. my wife is playing violin too :)