New reportoire... Help
So today my teacher that I should play new things.
We discuss and she decided that I should play kreutzer 12 (personally I don't like it...) and gave these options because I need to choose one: Fiorillo 13, Fiorillo 28 or Kreutzer 36. I really like Fiorillo 13 but it may be the most difficult one of this list
I finished Gavotte en Rondeau and she suggested Bouree (Partita 3) which I find quite easy, and Allemande (Partita 2). I like Allemande but I'd love to play the adagio (Sonata 1). I've already played the gigue (Partita 3) and double (Partita 1). Do you have any other interesting suggestion?
She suggested Beethoven Romance in F major and I suggested Brahms violin sonata n1 1st movement or Franck violin sonata 1st movement... Maybe I'll go with Brahms (I find it a little bit harder than Franck) but I would like any other piece/sonata you think it's good and at the same level as these suggestions.
She wanted to give me Kabalevsky but I said that I don't play Kabalevsky because I really don't this concert. It's boring and I can't even listen to it anymore.
I suggested Mozart 5, which is more challenging and she didn't said anything else. I really need more options. Although I really like Mozart 5, it would be interesting receive some new ideas...
Listen to your teacher. Leave the Brahms and Franck for a few years down the road. You aren't going to get much out of them at this point.
I agree with Christian. Your teacher knows better and is there to guide you
Some teachers including my daughter's violin teacher assigns etudes to address specific technical issues as they arise rather than go through the entire etude book so that part does not bother me although it is a bit puzzling that there was a "choice" so to speak. If certain etudes can help you fill gaps efficiently, why not learn all of them rather than just picking one? It isn't like choosing a concerto.
I also agree with Christian.
So your teacher wants you to play Kreutzer No. 12 and Beethoven Op. 50 before Mozart 5. Both the Kreutzer No. 12 and the Beethoven are often assigned to develop intonation security on the E string. The Beethoven also teaches some classical musicality. Both of those skills are absolutely essential for Mozart 5. And neither the Franck Sonata first movement nor the Fiorillo No. 28 will give you that. F28 has a few high notes but the main focus of that study is entirely different. Kreutzer No. 10 (one of my favorite studies of all time) is useful as preparation for No. 12 in my opinion.
Alfonso it is rather strange to say "I don't like Kreutzer 12'. It consists of arpeggios which are a necessary skill. Such rising arpeggio's as in Kreutzer 12 occur everywhere. You MUST acquire the skill to play Kreutzer 12 if you want to advance on the violin. Or, are you saying "Kreutzer 12 is boring, I can already do that"? OK then you may have a point. But for some reason I don't think that is the case...
My teacher allows me choices because my personal psychology for learning is if I hate something I will likely not practice it as much as I should and I will not learn as much as a different etude. However, this seems extreme. You should not question every single thing your teacher assigns. I had a teacher who was attempting to assign student Vivaldi’s concertos when I should have been playing stamitz concerto. I switched teachers and went through rep. And development much quicker.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.