Violin bright or dark sounding
Would you consider my violin to be bright or dark sounding?
Which is better, bright or dark sounding violins? Which sound do you prefer? Also, are generally more expensive violins dark or bright?
Do professionals prefer brighter sound?
It sounds on the mellow side to me. As to which is better, that really is a personal preference. It seems most people today ( non-professionals at least) prefer more mellow or darker violins so I think there are more of them being made. For me personally I tend to prefer the mellow sound; I have a very mellow sounding violin that I love, but I also have a very bright violin that I like and play regularly. ( I’m not a professional violinist though).
Dark violins for recording, bright ones for the concert hall. Or at least that's a very simple way of looking at it.
Wouldn't you prefer the third option, a violin that would do either, on request??
"Dark" can have different meanings. On one hand, it can mean depth, which is ideal when paired with brilliance.
Actually it seems that people with dark instruments try to brighten them up, whereas people with bright instruments try to darken them up!
When I was shopping for a violin, a local teacher who is also an excellent pro violinist advised me, "Paul you tend to play sweetly so you should avoid violins that are very sweet sounding." His reasoning was that I would entirely confine myself to that part of the sound spectrum and it would limit my growth as a violinist. He encouraged me to find a violin with significant brightness, which I did. But it is not a glaringly bright violin either.
I agree with Michael.
So maybe a violin that is between bright and dark is good?
To me it doesn't particularly matter as long as the instrument resonates. Which is true of both my violin and viola
After listening to the recording, it sounds as though your instrument may be leaning towards the dark side.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.