Concerning the G String...
I noticed something and it is that the g-string in my violin it's in a way "weaker" than the other strings, or in other words, less resistance to pressure. The thing is that, when in heavy stress or when i apply a big pressure over it, the pitch of the note gets like a lot sharper, and i tried it with my tuner and the difference it's about 30 hz. But when I apply the same pressure to the other 3 strings, their pitch doesn't change such a lot as the G, instead the max variation is 3hz, and it's catching my atention. Do you guys have the same "issue" or I'm the only one? With this problem, i can't even tune the G in 442 and i need to tune it a quarter tone flat so when i apply pressure it sounds right, because like i play a G Major chord and it is kind of dissonant(like, the chord in the start of the Mozart's 3rd) Also, how do you guys get over this problem?
The G-string should be louder than the D string. If the pitch changes when you try to play loud it is probably too light a gauge.
Are you using steel core strings?
simplest possibility that your string is simply worn out? how old is it? other than that: when you press more you also have to either increase the bow speed, or move the soundpoint towards the bridge. simply increasing pressure alone without changing the other two factors will certainly warp the frequency. on the E-string there is a well-known gimmick that illustrates that (playing the first five notes of "Fuer Elise" on the open E string).
And here I was thinking this was about concert attire.
Well, My standard stringset is Dominants for the G, D, and A, and a Pirastro Wondertone Gold Labeled E (tho for now i'm trying the Dominant' E, i'm not liking it very much). I have not changed all the 4 strings at the same time in a long time, i change 1 at the time, particullary the g string it might be old now, 4 months already but i don't think it's this the problem: i get this problem with every G no matter the brand or antiquity because i get the same issue with new strings and of other brands (i got the same with chromcor, tonica and vision), but never varying the gauge. I'll try that. Thanks for the reply!
Do you have the same issue if you substitute bow speed for bow pressure? Might also want to check the string height [setup] at the nut and FB end to see if that string is unusually high.
I wonder if the G string has not been broken in properly, so as a result sounding a little dull, or lacking in power or brilliance.
Thanks Trevor! This material seems very good, next time I change strings i'll try it, but i don't think it's a matter of string not breaking in properly because it's a bit old, I said like 4 months of use now. I don't think i'm stretching the string with my left hand because it happens also in open strings. And i've checked and the string is at the same height as the others. But i don't know if for the effect is the same bow speed as pressure. I'll test that. Thanks Michael also!
Plain Dominants shouldn't show that kind of trouble. Perhaps your bridge is badly shaped, or needs to be positioned differently? Have you run this all by a luthier?
Someone remarked on this forum some time ago that Warchal strings are Dominants that have gone to college!
I suggest taking your instrument to your luthier for diagnosis. It could be that your soundpost needs adjustment. In any event, the luthier can probably give you a better idea of what the problem is if not the soundest, e.g., age of string or something else wrong with the string itself.
It needs to be wider in Miami where a hotter moon rises two knight.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.