Sarasate Carmen Fantasy vs Tchaikovsky Valse-Scherzo
I was wondering how the Sarasate Carmen Fantasy and Tchaikovsky Valse-Scherzo compare in terms of musical and technical difficulty?
(Not planning on learning these pieces -- I was just curious)
Thanks a lot!
It may be a cop out to say that "it depends on your strengths and weaknesses as a violinist", (for example, I am atrociously bad at the one finger sliding chromatic scale), but canonically the valse scherzo is more difficult to get through despite being slightly less of a "showpiece".
Well yeah, the Waxman is way harder.
At that level, if you play well the Sarasate, you are not that many steps removed from the Waxman. Both are attractive in their own way. I do not see the Sarasate as a "poor violinist's Carmen Fantasy." I would gladly listen to either version in a recital.
The Sarasate one is really cheap. And after a quick Google search, there seems to be no sort of readily available bought edition of Waxman's Fantasie
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.