Bobelock and gewa violin cases
I'm planning to buy a budget case which is ethier going to be a fibreglass bobelock case or the gewa bio oblong violin case. But I'm having a hard time decide
What are your experiences with these types of cases?
Which one would you prefer?
Shaped or oblong?
For the gewa bio, oblong.
If your violin is worth anything to you, I recommend a plywood case for mechanical protection. My daughter has been using the Embassy Courier case ($149 from Shar) for about six years and it's still in great shape.
Would a wooden one be stronger than a fibreglass one?
Its more likely to be yeah
I'd highly recommend the new Gewa "Pure" polycarbonate cases, which only cost $220 (shaped) and $250 (oblong). They are well designed, scratch resistant, extremely tough, and have many features of cases costing two to three times as much. I recently bought both designs and have found them to be absolutely excellent! While I got the white versions since they do better with temperature regulation in direct sunlight, the grey model looks absolutely stunning.
I have a GEWA bio oblong that I purchased for my Yamaha YEV electric. It's spacious, which is good if you like to bring everything with you. (That's especially good with an electric, where you might want to carry a preamp, cables, and your shoulder rest too.) It has one fatal flaw, and that is that when you set it down on its edge, where the hinges are, with the handle up, it falls over onto its base. A huge design oversight. Mine is the simpler one of the two bio oblongs that lacks a music pocket and subway handle. Maybe the fancier one doesn't have that "fall over" problem, but I'd check before I bought it.
How strong would you say the gewa bio ones are? Like for example if I were to press on it?
Hi Gene, are the clips good on those things? I hope they last long.
We tested the Gewa Bio oblong in a crush resistance assessment in a lab at the Milan Polytechnic University and it performed surprisingly well. It's true that the shell flexes, however there is a lot more clearance between the lid and the bridge than most other cases.
Darren, the GEWA bio-s oblong is somewhat flexible under heavy pressure. It makes up for that by the spaciousness I referred to earlier. When my case is closed with my violin in it there's about an inch of clearance between the case top and the bridge. So it is a relatively safe case, especially at the price point. But it's bulky, though not heavy, and the hardware is kind of cheap, though functional. I also suspect that it's discontinued by GEWA, because most of the sellers who've offered it say that it's either out of stock or no longer available. A few sellers seem to have very limited stock. I honestly think you should look for something else.
How bout the bobelocks? Which one would be more protective?
Dimitri Musafia is likely THE authority on cases. If he is giving a qualified approval to the Bio case I would listen.
O ok, that's interesting!!!
There both great cases!
I once took a hard fall off a bike with my oblong Bobelock case on my back--that was the last time I ever rode with my violin--at any rate, my violin was barely even out of tune. I was not in nearly as good shape as my fiddle was, though.
Alternate career choice: violin transport. Crumple zones will protect case.
Bobelock cases have always been one of my "best-bang-for-the-buck" go-to's.
Bobelock is a classic. It's very consistent, it's strong, but it's also heavy and some airlines might give you a hard time over the size. I now use a Gewa case, because it is compact, light-weight, never had trouble with an airline. When I researched it I saw some studies Gewa published about their strength testing and I can't remember the details, but I wouldn't have bought it if I wasn't impressed. That being said, I doubt the strength of the case will ever be tested by me, because my case has never even been damaged. I treat my violin as gently as if it was an actual human baby...and that goes for the case as well if the violin is inside. I can't understand all these famous players I hear about who left their violin in taxis, buses, trains... etc. What kind of completely neglectful....anyway... that's enough out of me on that...cheers.
" I can't understand all these famous players I hear about who left their violin in taxis, buses, trains... etc. What kind of completely neglectful....anyway... that's enough out of me on that...cheers."
Im always forgoting things like leaving my bows everywhere lol. From lesson to even concerts! One time we had an orchestra tour down south,(6 hour drive) and after one of the concerts, while I was on the coach going back home, I had a funny feeling that I had left my bow at the concert venue, so I checked my case and it wasn't there. Then I had a panic attack because I knew my mother would kill me when she find out. Luckily a violist had picked up my bow and I couldn't thank him enough so I bought him McDonald's.
Well, that's a fair point, Mary. Perhaps my wording was a bit harsh.
Oh shoot, where did I leave my car keys? Has anyone never asked that?
I have two Bobelock fiberglass cases, a white 1060 oblong and a red 1007 shaped.
From my point of view, I have a Gewa Bio oblong, for a year or so. It is great case. For me is also great factor how it looks, and there has Gewa Bio great value for me over Bobelock, and second that they are much more expensive to ship into my country. Also sir Dimitri Musafia has recommended it here in some discussion, so I followed and I love that case, it is great. I am really careful, I hope will be fine :-).
tonareli fiberglass cases are nice, compact, and the straps feel good. if you live in a city i'd suggest a fiberglass case, much more durable and you can put cool stickers on it
"Also sir Dimitri Musafia has recommended it here in some discussion", I don't recall Dimitri "recommending" it beyong stating that it fared well in a crush test because of its high clearance. It's a relatively nice inexpensive case which I had for a short while, but replaced with a shaped Gewa Air which I felt more confident with to protect my relatively expensive instrument, but I wouldn't hesitate to use it for a $1500 or less instrument.
A recommendation depends on predicted use. I drive both an electric smart car (in town) and a Mercedes (on the road) - and would recommend both, but not if the purposes of each were inverted.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.