Hamilton vs Peak Folding Stands
I've need of a portable decent folding stand - my need is not immediate so I've time to look around. My teacher has a Hamilton Folding version that he has had for years, and I've also heard good things on the Peak. I looked in the archives but couldn't find anything more current than 2008.
Are the Hamilton and Peak comparable in quality? Any other folding stands I should consider?
I love my peak
Peak, hands down. It's compact, light, and sturdy.
I didn't know about this Peak. I searched on the web, and i saw it seems identical to a K&M stand that i own:
Thanks, I appreciate the information!
Chinese clone (Eastar make good flutes): https://www.amazon.co.uk/Eastar-EST-006-Portable-Violin-Retractable/dp/B07SG1X1PJ/ref=sr_1_1_sspa
If it is a music stand you require I recommend the K&M 10065. Much sturdier than the 101 model (or its predecessors) and not much heavier. If you sometimes need 3 or 4 pages side by side the K&M 10062 model is brilliant. Same legs as the 10065, but the music desk is extendable and the "wings" are in two parts.
I have a Peak that I use daily - it's easy to pack down into the bag and sling over the shoulder.
I have had 2 Peak stands. For the money they are very nice. You do have to be careful because if just one of the hinge "loops" of the desk breaks that entire "spine" will fail one by one.
I wondered if Catherine meant a violin or a music stand and came to the conclusion she meant a violin stand. Now I'm not so sure. She does thank Marco, who recommends a violin stand.
I have used a Nilton Magic portable stand for many years (https://www.amazon.com/Nilton-Magic-Stand-Made-Sweden/dp/B0046IVPX8/ref=sr_1_3?crid=1IB8ALTVW8W6E&keywords=nilton+music+stand&qid=1567610072&s=gateway&sprefix=nilton+%2Caps%2C122&sr=8-3). They are expensive but extremely convenient. The whole thing folds up into almost nothing and has its own carrying handle. Give what I have seen, including the Peaks (which seem good for the money), I would go with a Nilton; it is the Rolls Royce of the bunch.
We have 3 Voyager stands, and although we like and would buy again I don't like its quick disconnect mechanism for the desk - it is too easy for it to become loose or not be fully inserted and risks falling on your cello or destroying an iPad. So we replaced that with the fixed "model 74 neck assembly" for 9 bucks, effectively turning it into a standard Manhasset stand with lightweight folding legs. Very happy with this setup now.
Gordon - I was thanking everyone, didn't realise anyone had suggested a violin stand at all. I did mean a decent traveling (non wire) music stand that won't hurt my hands nor so heavy that it might cause other problems.
Are you looking for a desk or a supporting frame? Do you want to tilt the desk/frame for easier marking up?
David McLellan asked all the right questions. That said, I wouldn't give up my K&M 10700 folder (actually I have two of them). It's their top of the line folder, and it's admittedly heavy, but it's the most stable music stand I've used, including any non-folders. They make a carrying case with a shoulder strap for it. It extends high enough for an NBA player.
Good questions, I didn't think of those when I started the thread. I like my Manhasset, it's just too heavy/awkward to deal with to use it as a portable stand - and that's not what it was designed for. I don't see my ever playing outside so that isn't a concern.
I think if I was using my tablet mostly for musical stuff, I'd put velcro strips onto it so that I could secure it onto a music stand.
It certainly won't go anywhere Paul! If my hands/shoulders/neck weren't so arthritic I wouldn't hesitate to use my existing stand for traveling, but that is a game changer.
You can't go wrong with Peak as a traveling stand that will support a stand light like a Mighty Brite. If you buy Peak, consider the extra $10 or $15 for the model with aluminum legs instead of steel. Makes it quite a bit lighter to lug around.
I really appreciate all of the comments, thank you! I would love to be able to justify the Nilton Magic Stand, but the cost is unjustifiable, not at my level. I will check out all of the suggestions, thanks again!
Catherine - sorry you cannot justify the Nilton. I am not the world's greatest player, but at a certain point, I decided I did not want to put up with equipment that was cheaper but less convenient. The Nilton I have has lasted at least a decade. I expect it to last many more years. I consider stand lights in the same category. You spend a little extra to get something high quality that works for you. So, that's my $0.02 (or $134 depending on how you view it).
Good point Tom, and I may well reach that conclusion. I've been looking at it for several weeks now, before I started this thread.
Presumably, the Nilton case will also accept printed music? That may be a useful convenience.
I don't want to be the Nilton naysayer, but I was looking at the write-up on that and it says that the desk lip is only 1" deep. Either the write-up (at Shar) is mistaken, or that lip is simply not deep enough in my opinion.
The Manhasset is basically built like a tank -- it's steel. Practically every stand-attachable accessory on the planet is made for the Manhasset's metal desk. I often use the Stand-Outs stand extensions, and the pencil magnets can be used to attach pencils to the stand. It will take the weight of heavy music, a heavy stand light, etc.
Lydia, the Manhasset column and base are steel, but the desks are aluminum. I believe that Hamilton desks are steel. Is that what you meant?
Hi,I have a Hamilton stand,...with a pencil shelf under the music shelf.Very handy,and prevents my pencil going flying when page turning....