Fine Tuner for A - Russian Style!
I sometimes like to use a steel A string, Russian style, but I've never been happy with the fine-tuner options for ball-end strings. Yesterday I noticed that Gidon Kremer has an A string tuner that is different from the commonly available ones.
It looks kind of like a Hill or Goetz model, except that the metal block rests on top of the tailpiece instead of coming up from underneath. Does anyone know where I can get one of these?
Mutter, in her video of the Dvorak concerto with the Berlin Philharmonic, is clearly using the ubiquitous Wittner tuners for her steel A and E (as I do – but there the resemblance ends).
I would just get finetuning pegs.
Trevor, yes, that's what I usually use now, as the lesser weevil. I don't really like having those levers under the tailpiece though; I've also tried the - I think they're called "uni" tuners - but they lift the ball very high off the tailpiece and mess up the alignment. Oistrakh did the same, and had the same alignment problem, and it didn't seem to bother his Strad, but then again, it was his Strad... :)
Nate, I've used the "uni" tuners in the past, but no longer. I know they are lighter than the Wittners and the flat underside is less likely to do major damage in the rare event of a bridge collapse or similar, but I got fed up with that odd alignment, especially when there's a mute involved, and because the engineering design has a flaw that is not immediately obvious. I went into details elsewhere, but suffice to say that if an "uni" is tightened up on the tailpiece as it should then it becomes progressively more difficult to actuate the tuning screw and eventually the tuner starts to loosen, causing a mysterious buzz.
Trevor, same, especially re mute and buzzing!
Nate, the following link contains a catalogue of most known string adjusters together with links to the websites of the manufacturers:
Jose, thanks for the link; I've read that thread before. I have all of those tuners, except for the B&C one. I'm specifically asking about Kremer's A-string tuner as it seems to be not one of of the commonly available ones. I found a thread on Maestronet where someone was asking a similar question (had encountered one at a shop), but no one seems to know where they hail from.
Sorry Nate, I didn't know that you are already familiar with that cited thread.
Jose, no problem at all; I appreciate the input. It's better to have too much information than too little. :)
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.