How much progress can I expect as a late starter?
I am a high school student who started about a year ago. I’m 14 now. I wish I could have started earlier but it was not possible due to certain circumstances. I think I’ve been making fairly decent progress. I like my teacher and she is very good. She makes sure I master everything before moving on, which was annoying at first but I really appreciate it now.
I joined my high school orchestra and I can now play with them and not feel like I am inferior. Most of them started when they were 3rd grade or earlier (like 5 years is pretty common) but some in 4th or 5th. My orchestra teacher says I am doing very well and my private teacher says I play with good intonation and tone.
I do have areas I’m not so good at but I’ve been working on that and it has improved a lot- sometimes I do get a bit tense and that affects my playing. I can shift and play reliably in 1st to 5th position in tune. I’ve explored 7th position a bit but I don’t want to go too fast and develop bad habits. I recently got 2nd chair in our orchestra and I’ve been working on some of the simpler Mazas etudes which I found have been really helpful for solidifying shifting and rhythms.
I’ve had to learn a lot in a short span of time but I don’t think it’s been too terrible. It’s been a lot of work definitely. In some ways, I (and my teachers) feel like I could do better if I was more confident and willing to take risks. I’ve been trying that out the past few days. It’s been good so far.
Anyways, I wondering if I have a chance to get into our city youth orchestra next year which is a bit more advanced than our high school orchestra. I know some people in that orchestra and one of them, she says she’s been working on stuff like Sevcik and some Kreutzer. She’s a violinist.
I was also wondering what future progress can I expect?
I hope I gave enough info, but if not I can always add more.
Thanks in advance!
Among the string musicians I have known were a man in his 30's who was playing in the 1st violin section of the community orchestra 1-1/2 tears after starting violin lessons.
I believe Chabrier started COMPOSING quite late in life, also Havergal Brian.
One of the biggest impediments to late starters is this gem of seemingly inescapable logic:
Starting in the early teens isn't really a major problem, assuming that you are not trying to prepare for conservatory auditions. You just need to stick with it patiently, and probably take lessons through college (and beyond if you can), rather than stopping at the end of high school like many people do. People can and do become professionals with an early-teen start, but it requires a lot of extra dedication to catch up.
Probably as high as you want. I don't really think the problem is when you started. The problem is how much time you dedicate to the violin and how constant. I think the advantage with kids (3-10 years old) is that they have so many free time.
I had a friend with no prior musical experience who was able to play the Walton Viola Concerto to an acceptable standard (not concert soloist level, but all notes and rhythms well-learned with phrasing) after a mere three years of playing.
"I believe Chabrier started COMPOSING quite late in life, also Havergal Brian."
Seriously, however, Ida, it sounds like you are priviliged with good fingers and have the right study attitude, thanks to your teacher, too.
You can expect plenty.
Jonathan Vinocour, principal violist of San Francisco Symphony: started in a school music program in 5th grade (age 10 or 11) with no prior musical training, did not decide to pursue a professional music career until he was 20 or 21.
If you enjoy it, stick with it! Pay attention to your teacher. It's the grand experiment and you're the guinea pig. How good can you get? Find out for yourself!
I started at 18. I’ve worked through all of Kreutzer, Rode, Dont, most of Gavinies, most of Wieniawski l’ecole moderne, 20 of the Paganini caprices, Ysaye sonatas 1,2,4,5, and a bunchbof other stuff. My biggest problem is intonation. If I could conquer that, I would be too bad of a violinist. Unfortunately, it’s a big hill to climb for many violinists.
One challenge ( which may be applicable to a later starter ) I found as a returning adult is insufficient ear training at early age. This translates into intonation problems particularly in chromatic double stops passages—you cannot get it if you cannot hear it.
I started at your age and I'm a full-time musician. The only real problem I had to overcome was that I was almost dyslexic when it came to reading music. I overcame that a lot with work and found that I had strength where other people didn't seem to have them - playing by ear and improv. I think if I started younger I would have been so weened on reading music that those other skills would not have developed. Just remember that there is a whole world of music out there and you can find a place of your own.
I started viola at 14 yo, but with a background of piano (an "awakened" left hand) and choral singing (intonation). I found it easy to begin with, but had to analyse aspects which the young child absorbs more easily. This seems to have made me a thoughtful teacher..
I started at 11 but didn't get a real teacher until I was 14. I'm nothing to write home about, but my friend Janet started when I did in school and started private lessons a year before I did. She had a successful professional career. She wasn't a soloist, but she played with good orchestras, and in a quartet that travelled internationally. She said it was an uphill battle trying to play catchup to the kids at Meadowmount and Cleveland Institute who started at 4, but she got to have a career doing what she loved. So a lot depends on natural talent. Your teacher is the one to ask for an honest opinion of that.
Just realized you're a violist. That may help--they aren't a dime a dozen like violinists. :-)
I can't remember when I began the piano. The only piano I remember buying (£100) was after my first teacher died in 1974ish (when I was 14). But I had been playing for a couple of years before that. Either we had a cheaper piano I've chosen to forget about, or I practised in my nextdoor neighbour's house. It's a mystery.
@Elizabeth "they aren't a dime a dozen like violinists"
@Marty, I feel your pain. Intonation is hard. My approach is different. I'm not eager to play Paganini caprices out of tune. Maybe just maybe I'll eventually be able to play reasonable Mozart. I'll be fine with that. Embrace mediocrity!
Reasonable Mozart? That's the hardest thing in music. If you can do that, you're already a leading international soloist. =P
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.