The one in which we debate the merits of a tall chinrest
I've noticed that people talk about tall chin rests a lot, but I can't recall any knock-down-drag-out-shoulder-rest-style debate on the merits of adding height to chin rests. It is taken as fact that people need a taller chinrest. Tall chin rests have only become a thing in the past 10 so years- have our necks gotten longer, did we just not start using taller chin rests until recently because we didn't, or have physiological changes due to poor use necessitated taller chin rests?
I personally think that while some people actually do have long necks, generally, people hold their heads too far backward and up (Google images for tech neck and swayback), which requires a taller chin rest. But I've not really made up my mind either way.
Edited to add: If you use a tall chin rest, did you decide to do so after consulting a some sort of professional (Alexander teacher, etc.) who has specialized knowledge of violin setup and human physiology?
I got a taller chin rest recently because I noticed I was raising my left shoulder and playing felt awkward. I'm much less tense and more comfortable when I play now and it's improved my left hand technique. I think tall chin rests have merit if that's what's right for the player. there is no one size fits all solution and it's good for people to try out different things until they find what works for them
Julie, tall chinrests have been around a lot longer than 10 years. We were making or modifying them to be higher for people back in the 1960's, when I first got into the business.
David, were they as widely used back then or was it a somewhat rare specialty item? I don't recall them being mass produced or seeing them in catalogs until recently, and I never saw anyone using them or recommending them until a few years ago. I think Smiley Hsu was one of the first people I remember talking a lot about setups with tall chin rests. I have helped 2 very tall students purchase them. I'm not sure I'd recommend one as a remedy for a lifting shoulder though, as it could cause neck strain if your head's too far back.
Tall chin rests for tall necks.
Is anyone saying "tall for all", though? Sure, Frisch & Denig say that 90% of their customers need lifted chin rests, but that's likely more a function of people who need tall chin rests having a harder time finding something that works for them on the market.
"David, were they as widely used back then or was it a somewhat rare specialty item?"
I dont know, Craig, I'm small but need a tall setup so my shoulder doesn't compensate for the unusual weight of my instrument. I've been looking into these tall ones for a little bit and I might do it.
It seems reasonable also that a taller CR will be preferred by someone who wants to minimize or eliminate the SR.
I find that I am most comfortable playing my violin with a tall, slightly side-mounted chinrest and my shoulder rest on the lowest height setting. The alternative is to increase the height of my shoulder rest or live with terrible upper back pain because I've been raising my left shoulder. Both of these latter scenarios seem to have a negative effect on my playing technique as well. My viola, on the other hand, is a fair bit bigger, so I use a flatter chinrest with that. FWIW, I did find the 35mm SAS chinrest to be a bit too high on the violin, although I'm considering going back to that one next summer so I can experiment with taking the shoulder rest off completely.
I once moved to a Kréddle chinrest with medium height post + short setup Pedi shoulder rest, which reduced tension in my right shoulder, but eventually reverted to a middle of the ground setup with a traditional guarneri style ebony CR and Wolf Forte Secondo SR, which for the moment seems to work best. That may change over time however.
I still have my Forte Secondo somewhere, and would use it without much trouble if need be, perhaps on its lowest height (which is rather "medium" height.) The VLM Diamond made me not want to experiment much more with SRs, however, as it works so well for me. I find the Wolf much more flexible/adaptable than all the Kuns I have used in the past.
I am not an experienced violinst. I don’t consider myself one, at the moment. Just starting lessons. I did a lot of investigating to find out about chinrets and shoulder rests. I read a number of articles that stated a high chinrest allows you to use a lower shoulder rest. The reason those using this setup gave was that the lower shoulder rest and higher chin rest allow the violin to be lower, and still not have to bend the neck down. Keeping the violin lower makes it easier on your left and right arms because they are not held as high because the violin is lower. This, supposedly allows for more comfort, easier fingering and easier bowing.
Paul Deck said "It seems reasonable also that a taller CR will be preferred by someone who wants to minimize or eliminate the SR."
I think perhaps a “correctly sized for the individual “ chinrest will make playing without a SR easier. Is probably more appropriate.
I've never actually gone without a SR. However, it's a lot easier for me to get up into high positions on the G and D strings with a tall chinrest/low SR vs. a short chinrest/high SR. (High positions in general feel easier to me with this setup, it's just even more apparent on the lower end.) Octaves and tenths are also easier. It's not so much about security as it is about being able to reach every part of the violin that I need to without straining, raising my shoulder, or tensing up anywhere.