I find that even dark rosin does not meet my requirements for stickiness. I've started to use Pop's bass rosin on my bow, because it gives me the most snappy, bitey sound with plain guts (while also not being grainy). How some people use light rosin sparsely applied is absolutely beyond me...
Using light rosin was like trying to cross a frozen river wearing flip-flops holding a sack of bricks.
Maybe I've only tried crummy rosins? I haven't tried many, admittedly. Only 3 kinds.
Pirastro Gold, Kaplan Dark, and Hidersine violin rosin.
Magic Rosin has at least three grades of rosin hardness. The stickiest is their "X."
Can I ask why your requirements are different from those of other players (who are quite happy with all sorts of rosin)? Does it have something to do with your bow, your violin or the music you play?
For me the trick has been to develop better skill and responsiveness in the fingers of my right hand. It wasn't until I decided to perform a Mozart Sonata that I really understood how critical that was, but with the help of my teacher and by studying certain pieces (Mozart, Mozart, and Mozart), I gained a lot of ground. Still working on it, but I find now that I don't really notice it so much if I forget to rosin my bow when I start practice (usually it becomes obvious about half an hour in, though).
Give Melos Dark a try, sticky yet smooth for fine playing.
The better your right hand becomes and the better the bow that it wields the less "sticky" rosin you will need.
"Using light rosin was like trying to cross a frozen river wearing flip-flops holding a sack of bricks."
A popular dark rosin it looks like you haven't tried is Pirastro evah oliv. It's super dark and for me it feels good on gut strings.
It seems that keeping just the right amount of rosin on the bow is a fine point in the art of playing. Too little with a harder rosin and the strings can sort of "glass over" and refuse to react in a musical way. After playing a session where beautiful sounds and nice response flow the strings tend to be fully encased in rosin but almost no rosin dust lies on the instrument. The harder rosins might be less forgiving with the amount applied. I'm going to try Larica II to see if it is more forgiving than the harder, lighter rosin I've been using.
O P - Could your bow be too tight?
Well, switch to viola, cello and then double-bass rosin. Have fun.
I use inexpensive Hidersine Cello rosin for violin/viola.