I'm overseas and away from my workshop (AKA the unused corner of the furnace room), but I just had to do something about this intonation thing. It was driving me nuts, micromanaging my intonation (try remembering to finger normally on E and G, and flatter by up to a semitone on D and A, depending on where you are on the fingerboard). With pieces with lots of double and triple stops... don't even get me started.
Anyways. With some not-quite-the-right fit tools, I lowered the D and A strings pretty much to the limit of playability, and adjusted the nut for the extra width on the D string. It's high time for me to make a new bridge anyways, so it doesn't matter much. However, the D and A are STILL sharp---even as low as third position, fifths start getting real wonky.
No, it's not the fingerboard scoop/ neck relief. An actual luthier has played this instrument before and didn't have any complaints.
I emailed Pirastro, though, and they did send me a free, fresh set of Chordas. So, yay. Now I can prolong my suffering. Or pawn them off on my worst enemy.
Adalberto, from other posts I guess that Cotton simply is someone who enjoys tinkering. Sometimes I understand what he is trying to achieve, and sometimes I'm not completely sure about his intentions or the underlying problem. Like this time...
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.