I was looking at the Gold rosins made by Liebenzeller today and I was confused. I saw that there were different numbers after the word Gold on the box it comes in. What do the different numbers like I, II, III, IV and V mean? Do they pertain to the hardness, grade, or quality of the rosin?
I use III on the violin. It all depends, I think, on your climate and how sticky you want it. Gold I is too hard for me...not enough stick.
Thank you so much Sue. I was thinking about trying the Liebenzeller Gold rosin and was just wondering about what knid I should get. Thank you for helping me understand. I think I might go with I or possibly II. Thanks again.
Hi Josh,
I did a little reading up on Liebenzeller last year when I was hell-bent on finding the perfect rosin. I can't remember the source, but when looking for the difference between gold, silver and copper, I read that gold should apparently produce a brilliant sound, copper for warmth... and I can't remember what silver's supposed to do. But of course this could all be rubbish!:)
Gold I is very hard. You would probably need to be in an extremely humid environment.
I have tried Liebenzeller Gold II. Even the II grade is on the hard side. I think it's overrated for the price. The rosins still sold under the Hill name, and the Salchow, are better in my opinion. The Hill Dark is a sticky, grippy rosin that works well in dry weather. The Light is harder. I'd put Salchow in the intermediate spot. Nice stuff.
Liebenzeller used to make a "Meteorite" rosin as well.I used to use Silber 1(viola) and Gold 2,but now use a French product.
Well, after using a cheaper rosin for years, I treated myself to a L III...and I love it...I sound so much better! (And I need all the help I can get)...
...but I agree, there may be less expensive rosins out there that are just as good...all I'm noting is the increase in sound from a cheap rosin to an expensive one...
...I'm using the Bernardel on my viola bow...and am very happy with it as well...and it was a lot less expesive...
After being a years-long dedicatee of Bernardel, I decided to try Salchow's rosin after visiting their atelier in Manhattan. This is now definitely my favourite rosin. It also seems to be a little softer than Bernardel - after a year, it still hasn't cracked, even with my rough treatment. I used to go through four cakes of Bernardel a year - very brittle stuff.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Miroirs CA Classical Music Journal
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Coltman Chamber Music Competition
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
April 3, 2005 at 04:36 AM · Hi Josh,
It's grade. I and II for violin, I believe, with cellos and basses at the other end. I use II.