My understanding of just intonation is that it requires one to practice a sort of situational intonation, making each pitch fit within its harmonic context. Now, if I am playing F sharp in the context of a major third with D, it will need to be low. But if I add another third under the D and have a B minor chord, then the F sharp will need to be slightly higher in order to make a better fifth with the B. What do I do when a single pitch changes harmonic context while it is being held or reiterated? Say, for instance, the F sharp started out as the third of D major and then suddenly became the fifth of B minor? Do I change the pitch as I am playing the note? What if I am called upon to play a (high) E flat harmonized with a G below in a minor sixth, and then the E flat becomes the seventh of a diminished seventh chord built on F sharp? The E flat will then be too high, will it not?
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.