Bach's E Major Preludio has 1,635 notes, and I have a question about one. In measure 128, sometimes the eighth note of that measure is played G#, and sometimes it is played A.
The Galamian International edition has an A, with an asterisk stating "In most editions: G#".
The back of the Galamian edition has a reproduction of the manuscript, and that shows A.
The 1958 Barenreiter edition has an A.
The revised 2001 Barenreiter edition has an A.
I reviewed my recordings, and came up with a list. Here they are by the earliest date recorded:
Sarasate, 1903, G#
Szigeti, 1908, G#
Thibaud, 1936, G#
Enescu, 1949, A
Heifetz, 1952, A
Grumiaux, 1961, G#
Szeryng, 1968, A
Milstein, 1975, G#
Hahn 1996/7, A
Gringolts, 2003, A
Kremer, 2005, A
Tetzlaff, 2005, A
So, which note do you play? G# or A? Does it matter?
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.