February 29, 2012 at 4:28 PM
Have you ever heard someone saying how proud he/she is because they practiced tons of hours a day?
You wonder, how do they do it? Where do they find time to practice 8 hours and go to school, work, and be in touch with the social world?
For how long can you do that? Is it really effective?
Those were the questions that rumbled my mind for a long time. I needed some answers so I started reading personal development for classical musicians and even started a blog to help musicians. I tried to practice for 6 hours a day and do school and work but I felt totally burned out after 3 days.
Why was that? How come I couldn’t be like my friends at the conservatory? They seem to practice for 6-9 hours a day and do fine- at least that’s what they say!
After reading a lot and experimenting with different things I came down to 2 possible answers.
1) Either, my friends are rich and can afford to eat out every meal so they can go practice right away and not worry about work and school
2) They are lying!
I believe is the second one. I’ve read over and over again that you cannot be focus and maintain 100% of your conscious brain for more than 45 minutes- after that your mind needs a rest (mandatory). You might keep going and that’ll be fine with you but your level of productivity will definitely not be 100%- it will be lower with time.
After practicing for 3 hours with your demanding 10 minutes break for each hour, your brain has been put through such an intense period of time that you can barely continue been efficient anymore so it is recommendable to stop and do something else. Apparently my friends like to work at their 45% and think they are being productive.
4-6 hours in a row= wasting time- Perhaps for SUPERMAN works, not for us.
The best scenario would be to schedule your day before hand. Practice in chunks of 2 hours and focus on other things, then come back for 2 more hours, and so on. The masters recommend not to practice more than 5-6 hours a day.
When I feel totally exhausted and still need to do some practicing, I take 15 minutes break to lay down and close my eyes. I try to think about a white wall so my mind can have a little rest and forget about all the stress of the day. I found this very helpful even if I don’t fall asleep, my body is recovering and after that I usually practice 2 hours very easily with a clearer mind- it really works. This “technique” can help you accomplish anything during you day.
Give it a try and let me know!
I play the violin for maybe 60-90 minutes. I spend the other 8.5 to 9 hours wishing I was playing the violin.
-Mindful, careful practice for fewer hours (for instance, 3-5) is better than practicing 14 hours a day (although in all honesty they do not need be mutually exclusive.)
-Some people lie, but others are able to practice a lot. Some do it to brag, but others just feel so great after a productive day of practice, that they feel happy sharing what they are able to do.
uctured practice also tends to works better, although I admit not al people like (or even are productive) by following written practice charts/schedules to a T. We just can be so different from each other. But I admit having a sense of structure and setting daily and weekly goals (etc.) pushes practice (for whatever hours) to the next level of productivity.
-My own practice routine involves 50 minutes plus 10 minutes of rest=one practice hour. During that rest you can still practice mentally other things, or just close your eyes and just rest. But resting intervals are, IMHO, an important part of practice, so I do not consider it "lying" if an individual includes his ten minute breaks as part of his/her practice report. Must of us probably cannot practice 5 hours in a row without burning out (and perhaps even stiffling our development in the process.) It is important to find out at what time intervals we need even a little break, so that our practicing during the day can achieve its best results. The above works great for me, and even though I sometimes accidentally go above one hour without a break, I try to have a rest as soon as I see I've practiced over 50 minutes.
My current minimum us 3, and I try to go up to 5 or even six (if I can do it, then I go for even more). There's so much to do, improve, and memorize, and so many little techniques here and there that we can always work on. But violin playing is very strenuous, not only for the body (even when playing in the most relaxed manner), but even more so for the mind. Our minds and/or body often tells us when to stop or take breaks, and we should accept this and let our minds/body take such breaks. There's a point for each of us in which are practice stops being productive, and we should not focus only on the hours involved, but more on what's being effectively worked on. If one feels too tired or drained after 4 hours, perhaps one has had enough, at least for that practice session. I would say that learning what our limits are is useful. And we can always build up endurance and/or concentration levels up to the level in which we can actually practice a lot, AND at the same time, do so effectively. I do believe that at least 3 hours is quite good for a large amount of busy violinists (clearly, this is not a true "rule" for everybody), but that any other time that could be effectively added to it is always welcome-as long as you can benefit from those extended practice hours, and not just do it carelessly, just for its own sake or to "impress" somebody-always practice for yourself and your own needs, so you and your music gets the most benefit (which will ultimately be the most impressive feat, both for you and others.)
(I do believe that Galamian (and many others with similar advice) was quite accurate in recommending that very consistent daily (and of course, mindful) practice, even if for lesser hours per day, is often more productive than practicing this or that day for 13 hours in a row to "make up" for those days in which the violin was not touched.)
I also remember watching one of the interview of Perlman, he said he practiced 3 hours a day or something like that. Correct me if I'm wrong.
By following your own internal rhythm I think you are much more likely to avoid burnout - the danger in pushing yourself too hard. Practising for 8 hours a day only to reach a point of exhaustion and having to take a break may not actually give you any more hours and will most likely give you less quality.
This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.