Printer-friendly version
Karen Allendoerfer

Judging YAC

May 29, 2013 at 7:34 PM

The Philharmonic Society of Arlington's Young Artist Competition has been held yearly since 1965. I didn't know that back in 2008 when I joined the orchestra, or even more recently. It just seemed like, year after year, an amazing violinist--or cellist, or flautist, or singer--would show up at the rehearsals in February for the Family Concert and at one of the other concerts, and knock our collective socks off. This year, for the first time, I participated in judging the competition, known as the "YAC." It has two divisions, the Woods prize for players under 18 and the Tannenwald prize for players ages 19-30.

The competition is run by the coordinator, a horn player in the orchestra. I volunteered to assist her, and my main job was finding judges. It turns out this job is highly time-sensitive, because you have to know what kinds of applicants you have and find appropriate judges who understand their instruments. You may not have the applicant list set until about 6 weeks before, and then you have to get judges quick, before their schedules fill up. We had 5 judges for each division. In the Tannenwald division, where I was judging, I asked a German friend who is a professional soprano opera singer. We also had our choral conductor, the President of the Philharmonic society (who is a bass vocalist), a past winner of the YAC who is now a choral conductor for a local group, and me.

This year was unusual from the start, because we had 9 sopranos entering the Tannenwald division. Some years, I was told, we have no singers at all. There were also 4 violinists, a violist, a clarinet, and a countertenor. I felt good about being able to judge the violins and viola. The clarinet was covered by one of our vocal conductors who is also a woodwind player. But all those sopranos? Yes, I am a soprano, in a church choir, on good days. But still. To put it politely, I have one of those voices that blends well. I am not sure I would be able to tell the great singing from the merely good.

This year was also unusual at the end, in that the competition took place the day after the Boston Marathon bombing suspects were shot or captured in Watertown. Arlington was outside the lockdown zone, barely, but some of the contestants were coming by public transportation. We worried about what to do if they couldn't make it, when the lockdown was lifted and public transit opened, late the afternoon before.

There was one cancellation in my division, but the other 15 contestants arrived on schedule. Most were from eastern Massachusetts, but one had driven up from Pennsylvania, thinking about coming here for school, to study voice. As I mentioned, I was concerned about my ability to judge vocalists. I'm not an opera fan. I am sometimes skeptical when advised to try to make my violin sound like the human voice. I'd rather it sounded like a violin. And I tend to think that all opera singers, sopranos in particular, use too much vibrato.

But I needn't have worried. The other 4 judges knew plenty about how to evaluate singing technically, and I was pretty free to concentrate on the string players and on providing a non-insider's point of view on the vocalists. I came to appreciate classical singing much more that day, thanks to being a judge. There were songs from Candide, from Mozart, from Mendelssohn--religious, secular, and everything in between. For one singer I wrote on my score sheet, "otherworldly, I can see the moon rising." For the countertenor, I wrote "controlled strength and beauty." I think my socks were knocked off literally by the eventual first prize winner, who managed to fill the entire large church sanctuary with her power--without straining or using too much vibrato.

While I was entranced by the vocalists, I have to say that my own favorite points of the competition were the top two violinists, one who played Sibelius and came in 2nd, the other who played Vieuxtemps and tied for 3rd. The Sibelius player appeared a bit awkward and chilly until he put his violin under his chin. Then he mesmerized everyone with his beautiful tone and sure intonation. I'm somewhat ashamed to admit here that I don't know the Sibelius violin concerto very well. It's too difficult for me to play, myself, and I tend to prefer symphonies and sonatas to concertos, when I'm listening. But this was a wonderful introduction, a private performance that changed my relationship to the piece for good. And although I was in the minority of judges, I felt that the Vieuxtemps player was equally compelling, but that the piece he chose was not.

At the end, I wasn't as tired as I feared I might be. We were advised to write down something about each contestant to help remember him or her after several had gone by. My notes are full of descriptions like "bright red dress," "Joshua Bell face," "curly hair," "sweet face and voice," "bright blue shirt" and even "church lady." Sometimes I mentally stepped outside trying to listen for intonation or vibrato or phrasing and tried to just ask myself, "would our audience enjoy seeing and hearing this person perform?" I realized then that there is no one right way to present oneself, but there are some that are better than others. It's better if your dress isn't too low cut in the front, for example. But it's also better if you arrange your hair attractively and know what colors and styles bring out the best in your complexion and features. Unlike members of an orchestra or chorus, you don't want to just blend in, either.

When it came time to award prizes, there was a surprising degree of consensus in our division. We all picked our top 5 personal favorites, and were able to award the top 3 prizes without much deliberation. The discussion mainly centered around giving honorable mentions because so many of the contestants were deserving. I was a little disappointed to not give the violinist first prize, but I understood the arguments made in favor of the soprano by those who knew more than I, and came around to their point of view. I'm looking forward to hearing her in the spring. For the under-18 division winner, we have a teen cellist. After several violinists in a row, we haven't had a violinist winner for a couple of years now. Maybe next year. And I hope I'll be able to hear him or her play again, as a judge.

From Tom Holzman
Posted on May 31, 2013 at 2:04 PM
Karen - what a fascinating experience! My sense is that a really good musician can judge almost any instrument or voice, even if the musician does not play that instrument or sing. A good deal of what a judge looks for, I suspect, is musicianship, interpretive talent, imagination, and the like. I am in a quintet that has had coaching by professional musicians playing a variety of instruments, and all of them had good insights. I have a good friend in Paris who is a professional musician/teacher who plays winds, and I know he has coached string quartets. Anyhow, sounds as if you had a lot of fun.
From Karen Allendoerfer
Posted on May 31, 2013 at 4:30 PM
Tom, I think you're right, a really good musician can judge any instrument or voice, but we are talking about me here ;-)

All kidding aside, it was a great learning experience, I think for all of us. It's a treat to be in an orchestra that has a sister chorale, because not only do we get to perform pieces like Masses, Cantatas, and Oratorios, but we also get much more of an up-close view of singing as an art form. The soprano winner is "going places" and I'm sure we'll see her again on a bigger stage.

I also must admit that I didn't really have a clue about how much work the coordinator puts in. She's a volunteer like everyone else, and it's a major undertaking. You have to remember to do things like get the church piano tuned a couple of days before (and coordinate that with the church administrator). And get nametags and booklets printed up for the judges. And help entrants find accompanists. I'm happy to help but I would feel daunted to be the one completely in charge.

From Tom Holzman
Posted on May 31, 2013 at 5:31 PM
Karen - I am sure you are a good enough musician to do a fine job of judging. :-)

My orch also has a sister choral group, and all of our major concerts include choral numbers. At our concert this coming weekend, we are doing part of the Faure Requiem and some Handel with the chorus. I really enjoy playing the choral music, particularly the Messiah.

From Terez Mertes
Posted on June 1, 2013 at 3:43 PM
Very interesting to read!
From Karen Allendoerfer
Posted on June 1, 2013 at 3:51 PM
Hi Terez, thanks! Unfortunately, it took me over a month to get around to blogging about this :(

We're getting ready for our POPS concert now, and the end of the year is crazy in general. My kids are both leaving their current (elementary and middle) schools this year, and my parents' 50th anniversary is coming up. So, I'm feeling very behind, as usual.

This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.

Facebook YouTube Instagram Email is made possible by...

Shar Music
Shar Music Shopping Guide Shopping Guide

Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra
Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

Anne Cole Violin Maker
Anne Cole Violin Maker

The Soraya
The Soraya

Pirastro Strings
Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins
JR Judd Violins

Los Angeles Philharmonic
Los Angeles Philharmonic

Corilon Violins
Corilon Violins

Classic Violin Olympus

Coltman Chamber Music Competition

Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop

Jargar Strings


Violin Lab



Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews. Interviews Volume 1 Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn Interviews Volume 2 Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine