Printer-friendly version
Karen Allendoerfer

Can I really write a whole blog about bow distribution? No, I can't.

December 5, 2009 at 6:05 PM

But it seems to be a good example of what's been happening to me lately when I have a violin lesson.  I will be having a problem with something, like bow distribution, my teacher will point it out for that piece I'm working on, and then I'll see the issue everywhere I look, with everything I play.  Yixi was right, a beautiful sound really does come from the right hand.

I got back to the Franck 4th movement (however briefly) and expected to be slogging through the usual shifting challenges, intonation and vibrato issues, and trying not to screech.  And yes, that's all there, but with a new layer.  It turns out, it really matters how you divide the bow up in each note of a long slur.  The very first 5 notes of this movement sound different depending on whether you use more bow on the first note or the second.  It was counterintuitive for me to use more on the first B and less on the second C and third A, and then more again on the G and F down into the long E.  But just that made all the difference.  It changed the opening from sounding beaty and plodding to having more life and direction.  Hmm.

Then, about a week later, I suddenly got a small flurry of comments on YouTube.  I've had these videos up for more than a year, without much notice in the past.  They are of me playing the viola, specifically the Courante from the first Bach suite.  At this point, I feel pretty dispassionate about them, I haven't even really played the viola in several months.  It's almost like someone else is playing.  And why would this one, recorded in the rec room with my tinny-sounding digital camera, have been viewed 604 times??

Especially relative to this one, of the same piece, which was recorded by a friend with much better recording equipment at the Farmers' Market, which has only been viewed 372 times?

But anyhoo, the mysteries of YouTube aside, two of the commenters pointed something out that I'd been completely oblivious to at the time I recorded these:  that I spend almost all my time in the upper half of the bow.  I could plead viola in this case ("bow is too big!!"), but that would be wrong anyway, because here I am, a year later, having the same issue on the violin.  The internet just decided that this would be a good time to bring the point home?

This has been a busy week.  Last night, which was also my birthday, also happened to be the one night this week I didn't have something  violin- or holiday-related to do.  So I relaxed with my family.  But the night before, I played in my debut public string quartet performance.  One of the summer's musical soirees grew into a more regular group, and we played at Brookline's "First Light" Celebration.  The owner of the Real Estate office who hired us was wonderful, a lovely person who has deep roots in the community (and whose son took lessons from our group's cellist, which is how she knew of us).  I would love to do it again sometime.  

But there is also a reason that I am burying writing about what was otherwise a wonderful experience deep in a blog about something else.  After saying that I wanted to show up early to warm up, I ended up being 5 minutes late to the performance.  The reason had to do with my son's H1N1 vaccine.  There was a surprise clinic at his school that we found out about, by email, the morning of.  Then, I tried to delegate the task to his babysitter, but just as I was walking out the door to leave for Brookline, she came back from the school, saying that I needed to go with him to give consent and fill out a form.  She couldn't do it.  

I should have just skipped it then.  Maybe.  But I didn't.  We got in the car, ran to the school, got the nasal mist and then had to wait around for 15 minutes to make sure he didn't get a reaction, while I left messages on my quartetters' cell phones.  Then I brought my son home and tried again to go to Brookline, by which point the celebration was in full swing--driving in an unfamiliar area, kids with balloons everywhere--and parking was a zoo.  I ditched my car somewhere I hoped was not a tow zone and ran to the real estate office, arriving about 5 minutes after we were supposed to have started playing.  And indeed they started without me--now a violin, viola, and cello trio--on a couple of the pieces where I was playing 2nd.  I felt mortified.  And then I sat down, took out my violin, and started to play.  

As I played, I kept having this lingering fear in the back of my mind that my car was going to get towed, I was going to be stranded in Brookline and have to call and have my husband pick me up . . . and why hadn't the orgranizer of the group sent the email about parking that he had promised to send?? . . . or had it gotten lost or spam filtered? . . . and why does this kind of thing always happen to moms?  Of the four of us in the quartet, I'm the only mother--the only woman, in fact . . . I just read a really depressing study in which the researchers passed around fake job resumes, identical except for whether they mentioned they had kids or not, and the mothers were judged to be far less competent than the non-mothers, even when the resumes were otherwise the same--OMG what if it's true . . .  that wine they have over there looks really good, but not now when I'm playing . . .I really need to put this stuff out of my mind now, because it's nobody's responsibility but mine, and there's nothing I can do about it right this minute.  I just have to PLAY.

And believe it or not, I think I played surprisingly well.  After our medley of light baroque pieces, we went on to a full Haydn quartet, Op. 17 No. 2 in F major, where I was playing first violin.  The Minuet was probably the best we'd ever played it, and the Finale was humming along.  The people in the audience were sweet and friendly, someone from the Chamber of Commerce took our picture.  By 8:00, having missed 5 minutes out of 90 no longer seemed so dire.   The fact is, I *can* play under stress.  I just don't want to have to test that again any time soon!

But, tomorrow, I will be playing violin II in a last-minute concert of Elgar's "The Snow."  When I say last-minute, I mean last-minute for me.  The regularly scheduled 2nd violinist was ill, and I'm filling in.  This is, honestly, one of the most beautiful choral pieces I have ever heard.  I am so lucky to be able to be playing it.  And, there is snow expected tonight.  It's time!

From Francesca Rizzardi
Posted on December 6, 2009 at 2:32 AM

I can relate to your comment about seeing the upbow issue everywhere you turn.  A few weeks ago, two stalwarts each wrote about keeping the bow straight.  A few days later, I bought a new bow and discovered what an issue keeping the bow straight is for me.  I see it in every tough place of every piece I've been practicing lately.

Regarding being a mother:  You also mentioned recently that you're a doctor with youngish kids.  When you wrote about your birthday evening, I expected you to say that it was your first night in awhile since not being called for an emergency.  But you surprised me!  Your first night in awhile without a vioin-related event!  Let's see some GUY write a similar blog about balancing career, kids, and a demanding passion!  (Sorry--I guess all three are demanding.)


From Karen Allendoerfer
Posted on December 6, 2009 at 1:18 PM

 Hi Francesca, I'm not "real doctor" (heh heh), I'm a PhD.  I used to work in biotech on models of neurodegenerative disease and stroke.  A few years ago, when my son was 2, I took a job as a project manager in an academic lab.  I felt I needed more flexibility with kids.  (I have 2 kids, they are now 6 and 10.)  This job is almost entirely at a computer rather than the lab bench and some of it can be done at home.  It wasn't a coincidence either that about a year after I switched jobs I got my old violin out of its case, and rented a viola, for the first time in almost 8 years

This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.

Facebook YouTube Instagram Email is made possible by...

Shar Music
Shar Music

Pirastro Strings
Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins
JR Judd Violins

Los Angeles Philharmonic
Los Angeles Philharmonic

Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra
Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

Anne Cole Violin Maker
Anne Cole Violin Maker Shopping Guide Shopping Guide

Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Jargar Strings

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop


Los Angeles Violin Shop


String Masters

Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews. Interviews Volume 1 Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn Interviews Volume 2 Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine