Happy 300th Birthday to the 'Milstein' Stradivarius!

July 23, 2016, 5:45 PM · Bringing the "Milstein" Stradivarius to California has changed Jerry Kohl's life.

That is what Kohl told 300 people gathered to celebrate the 300th birthday of the Golden-Period violin, made by Antonio Stradivari in 1716 in Cremona, Italy. The celebration concert, featuring Los Angeles Philharmonic Concertmaster Martin Chalifour, Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra Concertmaster Margaret Batjer and LACO conductor and pianist Jeffrey Kahane, took place at the Huntington Library and Gardens' new Rothenberg Hall. Other fine instruments in attendance included the 1711 "Kreisler" Strad that Chalifour regularly plays, and the 1650 Nicolo Amati composite, with a table by Stradivari, played by Batjer.

Kohl, Batjer, Chalifour
Jerry Kohl, Margaret Batjer and Martin Chalifour. Photo by Violinist.com.

"It's changed my life, because they're magical," said Kohl, who is owner and president of accessories retailer Brighton. Watching his Strad on stage is a little bit like watching one's kid in a school play, "My child's on stage!"

Kohl is rooting for the fiddle to keep going another 300 years; "The people who own them care for them -- I'm just the custodian for the next 300 years," he said. And thinking about 300 years, "California isn't 300 years old -- there's not a building in Los Angeles that's 300 years old."

Most of the time, the instrument sits protected in a safe, in a nice, air-conditioned room. It takes a fine artist to bring forth its finest quality: that storied Strad sound. "When I have the violin at home, it doesn't sound like this!" he said.

To that end, Batjer, Chalifour and Kahane put together a concert that featured the Strad in music of many periods, styles and sentiments. In the printed program was a centerfold of the Strad, a fold-out with images of both its front and back. Have a look:

Milstein Strad
The 1716 "Milstein" Stradivarius.

Of course it all looked suspiciously fun to me. For example, the first piece, Martinu's Sonatine for Deux Violins and Piano, was playful and playable -- they described it as a new discovery for both of them -- and a rather do-able piece. (I'm determined to try it!)

Batjer drew some beautiful tones from the violin in Gluck's "Melodie," but the moment of pure Strad-sound rapture came during the middle movement of the Bach Double, with Batjer playing the "Milstein" and Chalifour playing the "Kreisler" Strad. Bach knew what he was doing; so did Stradivari, and so did these three fine musicians.

They closed the concert with the "Dance Espagnole" from "Navarra" by Sarasate -- great show-offy fun with two wonderful violinists and a great pianist. What a joy to watch them!

During a break in the music, Kohl described how the idea to buy a Strad first came to him, more than 10 years ago. His daughter had suggested that he invest in precious paintings, but that didn't capture his imagination. When it came to the arts, Kohl was a lifelong guitarist whose interests lie in music. But how exactly could he make that into an investment?

These were the kinds of thoughts circulating in his mind when he read an article in the Los Angeles Times that sent him down an entirely new path. The article described the journey of the "Duke of Alcantara" Stradivari violin, an instrument that enchanted its various "owners" with its sound and was at the center of something like a great custody battle, as it was lost, found and fought over in lawsuits.

"I had this crazy idea of buying a Stradivarius violin," Kohl said. Kohl was fascinated with the kind of attachment people seemed to have to Strads, and to the great value attached to their mysterious qualities. He also read that Strads were being bought up by wealthy patrons in Russia and China, and he liked the idea of bringing a Strad to the United States.

The first person he called was Los Angeles Philharmonic Concertmaster Martin Chalifour; then he also talked with Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra concertmaster Margaret Batjer. Little did he know the two violinists were longtime friends; they both readily agreed to help him in his search.

He also enlisted the help of Google, which quickly presented him with the message: "Buyer Beware!" The Internet described violin dealers as being rather crafty. "I thought for a long time," he said, and then he called a lot of people for advice, including the head of the Smithsonian Museum in D.C, which keeps several Strads in its care. He was advised by Sotheby's that Strads rarely simply come up for sale.

"The people who own them care where they go," Kohl said. Though a Strad owner won't necessarily put the instrument on the auction block, he or she might be convinced to sell the instrument to the right buyer.

So Kohl found the three of most respected violin dealers in the world. (One who is now in jail!) Together, they brought him eight Stradivari violins, two from Chicago, three from London, two from Austria and one, Jack Benny's violin, from Los Angeles. Chalifour and Batjer tested the fiddles for Kohl during a private eight-hour "violin play-off" at Walt Disney Concert Hall.

MilsteinThe "Milstein" Strad, stood out especially to Batjer, who recognized the distinct knots on its belly and was overwhelmed with the implications: that this was the violin she'd heard in the hands of one of the top violinists of the 20th century, the Russian-born American violinist Nathan Milstein, who had died in 1992.

"I knew exactly what violin it was, and I started to weep," she said. "Playing it on a regular basis -- that has been one of the greatest pleasures in my life." Not only that, but the violin was made during Stradivari's "Golden Period," considered the time of the maker's best work.

The "Milstein" Strad was actually not exactly "for sale." It had been sitting in a vault for 13 years, and the family had some specific ideas about how they wanted it used. "They weren't willing to sell it to a violinist, but they were also not willing to sell it to a museum," Kohl said. They wanted it played, but not played all the time. Kohl purchased the violin from the Milstein family, through Charles Beare of Beare's in London, for an undisclosed price. At this point, the violin is played in concert about 10 times a year.

What is it like, to play on such a historically significant and valuable violin?

"It's a conversation, and it's a privilege," Chalifour said. "When you learn to play the violin, you learn control over the instrument. But with a great violin, you have to make compromises and learn how to extrapolate its best qualities."

BELOW: Martin Chalifour gives a short demonstration on the 1716 "Milstein" Strad:

You might also like:


July 24, 2016 at 07:56 PM · Interesting!

One of my daughters (different last name) happens to work for Jerry Kohl, and the Brighton line of stores.

July 25, 2016 at 05:39 PM · Yes I imagine a priceless antique violin would be quite the conversation piece and it appears that the instrument also serves as a kind of backstage pass. "You bring the nachos. I'll bring the Strad." Something like that.

July 25, 2016 at 06:11 PM · It's pretty cool to have a Strad in residence nearby; it attracts fine players, historians, luthiers, listeners, and also it creates a live and local connection with the violin world, for people who might not normally think about it. Kohl has been generous in lending it out and meticulous in caring for the instrument. Certainly that beats sitting in a vault!

July 30, 2016 at 07:18 AM · Being the first private pupil of Nathan Milstein in London at his Chester Square home., due to having the Concert Artist Management in London, Mr. Milstein invited me to play the Chaconne of Bach from the d minor Partita, No. 2, knowing I had also studied with Jascha Heifetz in his first international Violin Master Class at USC, with classmates Erick Friedman, Carol Sindell, Varoujan Kodjian. Robert Witte, Adam Han Gorski and Claire Hodgkins, all of which were subsequently filmed with each of us having a full half hour lesson/performance film with Mr. Heifetz, (now available on YouTube, mine being Khachaturian 1st mov't, JH-7, Elisabeth Matesky). Mr. Milstein had seen my film when touring in America. Being honoured to be what Milstein loved calling me, 'my (his) guinea pig!", I had the glorious experience of having up to 3 or 4 hour private artist lessons twice a week when he was resident in London, revisiting all the major Violin Concerti repertoire, and, yes, Bach's Unaccanied Sonatas & Partitas for Violin + many concert pieces & Milstein's 'Paganiniana'! This 'blue period" of what I refer to as "Milsteiniana" lasted 3 & 1/2 years during which time Milstein completely changed my bow arm and greatly enhanced my musical palette & person ~ During many of our sessions he would invite me to "Please play my Strad, Elisabeth, so I can hear how it sounds away from under my chin today, just to check!" (He also loved my special Italian fiddle!). I know the 'Marie-Therese' Strad of my great mentor and friend, Nathan Milstein, very well & can attest to its remarkable sound qualities but wish to say I'm not surprised to read Jerry Kohl say something to the effect that this great instrument doesn't sound the same. Mr. Kohl, if you read this, I must tell you that what is now being referred to as 'the Milstein Strad', reflected the uncanny sound and musically rich caresse of it's Owner, Nathan Milstein, and upon ite 300th Birthday, July 17, 2016, with all due respect to violinists Martin Chalifour & the daughter of the late Eleanore Stanlis, Margaret Batjer, Mr. Milstein's Strad is still weeping for its longtime departed Owner ... I truly believe in Nathan Milstein's hands , his Stradivarius, Violin, circa 1716, was the greatest violin in the World of its creator, Antonio Stradivarius ~ Having known Mr. & Mrs. Nathan Milstein until each, respectively passed (NM, 12/21/1992) and TM, in the later 1990's), having shared nearly 24 years of music and friendship with them both, I miss them deeply and being up close and personal to NM's treasured Stradivarius which he played non stop until his tragic accident, being hit by a crazed driver just outside his London home, rendering the only peer of Jascha Heifetz, unable to play ~

How fortunate you are, Mr. Kohl, to be close to my violin mentor's best friend ... At least the violin is in America which was Nathan Milstein's adopted country whom President Ronald Reagan greatly honoured in December,1987, with the Kennedy Center Honours Award ...

Please continue taking great care of my teacher's heart and soul ~ Tearng up. I remain

Yours musically from Chicago ~

Elisabeth Matesky

This article has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.

Facebook YouTube Instagram Email

Violinist.com is made possible by...

Shar Music
Shar Music

Pirastro Strings
Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins
JR Judd Violins

Los Angeles Philharmonic
Los Angeles Philharmonic

Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra
Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

Anne Cole Violin Maker
Anne Cole Violin Maker

Violinist.com Shopping Guide
Violinist.com Shopping Guide

Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Jargar Strings

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop



Los Angeles Violin Shop


String Masters

Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine