February 2013

Music From the Inside-Out

February 16, 2013 18:17

As a professional classical violinist who performs regularly for audiences in New England, I often wonder about the role of classical music in our society. Many people who do not understand our art view what we do as elitist or snobbish at best. Rather than expounding on this belief and placing blame, instead I wish to comment about how I see the future of our industry evolving.

Classical musicians today live in wonderful times for our art. Yes - That is what I said - WONDERFUL times. While it is true that the respect for our music has waned, I contend that never has the potential for success of the individual musician ever been so great.

You see, in the glory days of violin playing, which can roughly be categorized from around 1920-1980, there were many great performers who took advantage of the new technology of recording to spread the "gospel" of classical music. Never in the history of the world had musicians been able to reach so many people in the comfort of their own homes. The downside of this blessing was that these musicians were required to fit a certain mold. Getting a recording contract was tough and the market was saturated with many players trying to constantly impress the big labels. Only a few slots were available and the performer had to be "sellable", as far as the label was concerned. As recording technology blossomed, I believe that the individuality of the performer was stymied as a maniacal drive for perfection and virtuosity became the name of the game. In essence, the messages in the music and its importance were lost. This drive for perfection was also exacerbated by the recording engineer's ability to "cut and paste" music digitally.

It is my contention that we are on the threshold of yet another glorious period of classical music. The difference, this time, is that the purpose of performing is radically going to change. Whereas in the past musicians were required to fiercely compete and prove themselves worthy of a performing and recording career, it is now the performer's ability to relate to the audience on an individual level that is paramount. Yes, playing at a high level is very important, but it should not be the be all and end all. Rather, it is the message in the music that really resonates with us.

While it is true that Western Culture has unfortunately largely abandoned the torch of understanding the Classics (whether in literature or music), the challenge of our generation is to present a story that is compelling enough that the listener understands the message of the composer as interpreted by the performer. In other words, our audiences will not come to hear us in person or buy our recordings for culture's sake, but rather because they are inspired by our story. This story is unique to the performer, just as it is to the listener.

The beautiful thing about classical music is that unlike the popular culture of the masses (such as Brittany Spears, Beyonce, or Lady Gaga), our music comes from the inside-out. I can see it now - some of my readers are now thinking "WOAH...What kind of snotty statements is this guy making!" Folks, please allow me to elaborate and keep an open mind while I do so.

The most successful popular music in society today, in my humble opinion, has been designed to come "from the outside-in". In other words, the role and purpose of music for the masses is to make the individual feel "high" off of a loud, sexy, and sometimes angry performance. This is a generalization, I know, but there is a large element of truth in it as I see it.

Where classical music often differs is in the fact that the composer was not trying to get a certain reaction from the audience. Rather, the composer would see his or her world and reflect this in music. This reflection comes "from the inside-out". For instance, the late Beethoven string quartets demonstrate a rich and vivid emotional world that the composer imparted to us even at the end of his life and after he had lost his hearing. In effect, what classical composers are doing is they are asking the audience to join them in experiencing their internal journey. The most relevant and successful composers are those whose music seems to relate across generations.

At the end of the day however, it is up to the performer to interpret the music how he or she sees it based on the conventions of the generation. This is what we call "taste". It is a reflection on who we are as individuals. After all, our emotions, needs, and yearnings do not change on a fundamental level.

Just to play the devil's advocate, one could argue that the music of pop culture does resonate with us across the generations but I believe that this happens on a more base level. Yet, there comes a time when many people feel that this type of hypnotic culture isn't enough for them. They yearn to feel a deeper connection with the performer and composer.

Coming back full circle, with the rise of the internet, today's classical performers have so many tools at their disposal to share their interpretations of music. Youtube, Kickstarter, and Nimbit are just some examples. While it is true that the internet does not very easily allow the average musically uninformed person to find out about new talent, it is a great facilitator of selling one's art once that relationship between performer and audience has been established.

There is another mixed blessing relating to the times we live in. The average individual expects online music to be either free or at a very low cost. On the other hand, this "giving away" of music can result in an artist's reputation going viral. In the past, musicians were expected to appear in concert in venues around the world or at the very least, around the country. This was taxing on any individual and family life was compromised. On the other hand, this model resulted in music being seen as a necessary and important diversion from day to day life. A concert was (and largely still is) seen as a way for the individual to relax after a long day or a long week. But then, is that what we musicians want? Is our music really just a diversion? (This is an open ended question whose solution is not readily available today either). In today's society, however, we have even lost the ability to stop and smell the roses.

It is my contention that in the future, the nature of the instant communication that the internet provides will allow performers to spread their message without the need to appear "in person" as much. This is possible because the consumer, who expects free media on the internet, will be able to "try out" some of our recordings without any risk before making the decision to buy. This new business model also fits nicely with the fact that most listeners today are more likely to listen to their music for shorter periods of time, often in the car on the way to work. This is a reality that we musicians must face.

The upside to this is that the repeated hearings of music that truly resonates with the individual can result in the artist achieving a live following, particularly on the local level. In fact, it is at the local level that audience building must start. Only after developing a local following can the internet truly help artists get the word out, as word-of-mouth takes its effect.

How does one get this following? My belief is that because we all have a unique story to tell, it is up to the artist to make himself or herself relevant to the particular audience. After all, beauty truly is in the eye of the beholder. If artists focus more on the message behind the music and cultivate a sense of real authenticity, I believe that they will be successful.

Daniel Broniatowski, D.M.A.

11 replies

Learn How to Play Violin!

February 4, 2013 20:28

How to Hold the Violin and the Bow

Welcome to the third and final series called "How to Play the Violin". In part 1, we examined the parts of the violin. In part two, we covered the parts of the bow. In part three, I will take you through a step-by-step guide how to hold the violin and the bow. Please note that nothing replaces actual lessons with a qualified teacher but this is a great way to read up on the topic before your first lesson!

Sometimes, a picture is worth even more than 1000 words. In our discussions, you will find this to be the case.

So, let us begin!

1. Stand in rest position. Notice that my feet are together and the violin is tucked under my right shoulder. The instrument is cradled under my arm and is held loosely with the upper arm over the strings just above the tailpiece.

2. Now place your right foot to the right so that it is under your right shoulder. Lean ever so slightly on your left foot. Then, pretend that your left hand is a hungry crocodile and make a pinching motion (without chomping tightly) with the fingers and thumb. Your hungry crocodile oddly likes to eat violins. Take your left hand and "bite" the lower bout of the instrument (that is, the "shoulder" of the violin that is closest to the floor).

3. Make sure that the left thumb is touching the top of the back of the instrument, just below the neck.

4. Then, use your left hand to remove the violin from under your right shoulder and hold it straight ahead - right in front of you.

5. Next, turn your arm (the one with the violin) counter-clockwise so that the button (that is the tiny black part that is on the very bottom of the violin) points upward toward the ceiling (or at least as close as you can get without feeling tension in your arm). Note that most people (including myself) cannot turn our arms around fully unless you are double-jointed.


6. Then, bring the violin "in" so that your chin rests just above the tailpiece (NOT the chinrest!) Remember what we discussed in the first blog post about the chin not going on the chinrest? Well, this is the time to get it right, lest you develop bad habits. Also, remember how we discussed needing a proper fitting for a shoulder rest and chin rest? This step will not work properly if you haven't yet done so.

And that is how you hold the violin!

Let's now cover how to hold the bow.

This is a little more complicated.

Please be patient with yourself when doing this. Many students get frustrated when learning how to hold the bow. Furthermore, when playing, it is very easy for beginners to lose the proper bow hold. If you can, try to spend a few days focusing only on how to hold the bow before you attempt to play. You'll be happier in the long run!


1. We're going to make bunny rabbits! Try your best to replicate this "pose". Note how the thumb is gently curved under the first joints of the two middle fingers. This is the nose of the bunny. The ears, or the other two fingers, are nice and curved. Make sure that your entire hand is loose and nothing is tight or clenched.


2. Here is how it looks from the side.

3. Holding the bow vertically on the stick with your LEFT hand (we'll call this the "helper hand"), make your bunny rabbit in the right hand. The tip of the bow should be at the top, toward the ceiling As we spoke about in the parts of the bow, remember not to touch the horse hair! Very carefully with both arms straight out in front of you, turn your bunny rabbit sideways, so that the thumb is closest to you. In your left hand, make sure that the bow is being held with the hair away from you.


4. You may wish to do this part in front of a mirror. We are now going to deconstruct the bunny rabbit and reconstruct it with the bow on the inside of the bunny. Take your right thumb and let the center of it touch the corner of the frog. The corner is the top-most protruding part of the frog that meets the stick.

5. Now, with your thumb curved, place the bunny's nose on the other side of the frog. Only the first joints of the two middle fingers should be touching. Now, place your index finger on the stick so that the side of the finger touches, just above the middle joint. Then, rest your pinky ON TOP of the stick and try your best to keep it curved.


5. If you can, try to move the bow horizontally. And that is how you hold the bow! Good luck!

For more lessons like this, be sure to check out my violin videos at www.violincoursesonline.com

-- Daniel Broniatowski, D.M.A.
Violin teacher serving Watertown, Brookline, Newton, and greater Boston, MA

12 replies

More entries: December 2012

Facebook Twitter YouTube Instagram Email

Violinist.com is made possible by...

Shar Music
Shar Music

Pirastro Strings
Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins
JR Judd Violins

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

2023 Authenticate LA: Los Angeles Violin Shop
2023 Authenticate LA

Violinist.com Shopping Guide
Violinist.com Shopping Guide


Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Jargar Strings

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop



Los Angeles Violin Shop


String Masters

Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine