February 6, 2009 at 6:28 AM
One of the things I have noticed about the adventure of learning to play as an adult compared to my experience when I was younger is that I can be much more analytical and purposful in my practicing. I am much more aware of what I need to do to progress, and many of the things I was told (such as not practicing your mistakes) I actually TRY to pay attention to. Still practice to me is an elusive discipline.
For one, I never seem to match up with even my own understanding of good practicing theory. Even when I set out to have a great practice in terms of discipline and good habits I often find myself missing the mark. For example, when practicing a particular section of a piece I always seem to want to try to play it at temp, even if I cannot. When I force myself to slow down, I do briefly, but then there I am speeding up again. Or I will make a few successive attempts at some difficult aspect of technique, but will give up before really making any progress.
These issues I suppose are largely matters of discipline and also fighting against habits. However, sometimes I will get into a zone and practice something difficult at a good tempo to learn and will find myself engaged in that difficult technical challenge. It is at these times when the practice session is really working and I am feeling the effectiveness of the methods. Perhaps that is just it, sometimes I don't feel the effectiveness of slowing down or I am not making those very small gains in progress on that technical challenge which spurs me on.
In fact, I think the issue of very small but measurable progress at a single practice session is one of the keys to having a great practice. By seeing even tiny advancing steps I become motivated to continue and work to overcome the challenge. When I fall out of good practice habits, I wonder if what is happening is a kind of minor frustration borne out of not feeling even small sucess which causes a bit of grasping at just trying to do it any way possible. I suppose it is mostly inexperience in these situations which is preventing me from recognizing what is causing the lack of progress and what I need to do to overcome it. The skill in recognizing not only what is wrong, but what small steps and small victories are the path to overall sucesss is a valuable skill to learn.
The second issue with respect to a practice ideal and my woefully inadequent attainment of it is one of a more broad and general nature. Typically I have learned a certain kind of practicing discipline is ideal whether it flows through a schedule of warm up and scales, technical exercises, studies repetoire and performance practice say, this is an awful lot of items to fit into a practice session. I find that more often than not I will be enthusiastic and motivated on one of those particular items and spend most of my practice session on a single thing. Now I understand that overall one must have a good balance in what one practices, and it would be a mistake to only practice what we are enthusiastic to work on and leave out those boring (or difficult) but necessary bits. However, I think one should have the latitude to dive into something even if it means missing a few other items that day. I believe this can be beneficial because when you are engaged and motivated you are usually learning optimally as well.
So, how does one find a balance of discipline , maximize enthusiasm and engagement and learn to recognize what it takes to secure small victories while working on a technical challenge. I suppose learning these skills is as important to good development as the specific skills need to play the instrument.
please visit my other blog at
This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.