My experience bears out the wisdom of advice I've read on v.com several times: If your setup is unsatisfactory, then, before adding or ditching a shoulder rest or changing to a different one, first consider the chin rest.
In summer 2005, when I first tried the Flesch flat chin rest, a popular model centered over the tailpiece, I liked it right away. In general, all seemed well these last 8 years; yet there was a subtle nagging feeling that something was a bit off. Since using the device didn't degrade my playing or cause discomfort, I largely ignored the feeling.
Then, in early May, one in-home session of comparing this model with two others I'd used before helped me pinpoint the problems: 1) The Flesch flat model was too tall for me. 2) It made me hold the instrument farther left than I wanted to. 3) It made me point the scroll farther left than I wanted to.
So what did I do? I detached the Flesch and substituted a Guarneri rest from my collection for comparison. That helped me hold the instrument a little more to the right and point the scroll more toward the front; but I no longer felt comfortable with this model, even when covering it with the Strad Pad, a detachable, washable chin rest cover.
Next I pulled out a vintage rest from my student days. It reminded me of the Teka medium -- same basic shape and size. On two fiddles, this one was too tall for me; but on the third fiddle, it worked great. I couldn't safely use it now; one bracket would no longer remain securely in place.
So I ordered a new Teka medium, which works great on this third fiddle. The other two instruments now have Dresden mediums, which are shorter.
What freedom regained -- not to mention the enhanced feeling of security. Indeed, sometimes it turns out that the old way was better after all. Oh -- what is that classic song -- "I Could Have Danced All Night"? Well, I don't know how to dance, but I felt as if I could have fiddled the night away -- out in the garage. Be assured that I didn't -- for three reasons: 1) I'm not a night person. 2) I try to be a good neighbor. 3) 4:40 AM -- rising time -- comes fast.
Treating the viola like dirt? Not at my place.
For one thing, I've never owned or even rented a viola. In fact, I don't recall ever handling one. And I don't read the C clef fluently, although I'm familiar with it from reading orchestral scores -- a pursuit I picked up in my teens.
I love the sound of a viola -- always have. Probably my main barrier to playing one, besides sub-par C-clef fluency, is having three older fiddles already and spending about 3 hours a day playing them -- 1 hour per fiddle. On the 1869 and 1883 instruments, the stiff versions of Pirastro's Eudoxa or Oliv (Olive) D and G strings bring out a viola tone in the contralto range -- especially on the 1869 instrument. So l get a partial viola "fix" by working a good dose of sul G tones into the daily warm-up.
The viola is also one of several instruments I associate with animal or bird life. Flutes remind me of birds. Oboes remind me of kittens. Bassoons remind me of cows. And violas remind me of -- bullfrogs. That's right -- just like the ones I heard in the Lower Peninsula of Michigan as a kid. No -- that's not a viola joke!
The only remaining barrier is hand size -- maybe. While I don't have quite the problem another v.com writer described -- puny paws and diminutive digits -- still, my hand size, M (medium), is toward the lower end of the range: S-M-L-XL-XXL. I can vibrate with the 4th finger sul G on the violin in 1st position and can play 10ths. But to stretch the left hand any farther than this? You ladies, who generally have smaller hands than we fellows have: How do you manage it? How is it that so many of you take to the viola so well?
Maybe, if I just plunged in and tried it myself, it might not be as tough as I thought. For now, though, I'll just sit back and enjoy the music -- and be thankful that there are others, whether ladies or fellows, who give time and talent and effort to play this seductive instrument.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.