Written by Zlata Brouwer
Published: January 29, 2015 at 9:37 AM [UTC]
You can place this device on your instrument and according to D’Addario this device can serve you in three ways:
You can adjust the tuner, so it fits your violin or viola perfectly. You can safely place it on your instrument: it won’t damage your instrument (if you don’t do strange things) and it won’t fall off. The tuner responds much better when you bow vs pluck.
Of course you always have to tune your instrument yourself. This is not a device that actually tunes your instrument. It just indicates what’s the pitch and it’s too low, in tune or too high.
The tuner works with whole tempered (piano) tuning, so the fifths are a bit narrower than perfect fifths. When you want perfect fifths and you can tune by ear, use a tuning fork or just tune your A string with this electronic tuner.
The metronome function is more like a little extra and is quite limited. The metronome is only visual: it doesn’t make sound. You can adjust the tempo by clicking on two buttons. A larger metronome makes sound and is easier to adjust from one tempo to the other without clicking a button loads of times. It’s handy that the metronome function is there (for on the road), but in daily use you probably want a separate metronome. This device is mainly meant to be a tuner.
There is some discussion about the third function: checking your intonation with the tuner while playing.
First of all: when you tune your violin in perfect fifths instead of piano tuning, your G and D will be indicated to be a little low by the tuner and the E will be indicated to be a little too high. These differences are very small, but they can bother you when using this device to check your intonation.
The response of this device is very quickly as promised. You can see if you are in tune while playing, certainly when you are playing slowly and carefully.
As a teacher I can totally image that this sounds like a must have. Lots of people are very insecure about playing in tune and long for some way to check if they are when practicing.
This sounds very good, but it comes with a warning from my side. When I’m practicing I often check my intonation with my piano, so I also use something to check myself. When you check with the piano, you need to hear the pitch and compare it to your own. Your ear is more active in this case.
Checking yourself with the tuner is very passive: it just tells you whether you are in tune and you don’t have to use your ear. You just have to move your finger until the tuner indicates a green light.
For this reason you must be careful when you use this device. Don’t use it all the time, because your ears will become lazy and you will only depend on your eyes. You will not be able to play the piece in rhythm and in tune. Don’t become dependent on it, because it will work against you. You won’t learn the motor skills and you won’t train your ears. Chances are your intonation only gets worse as your ears get lazy.
When you use this device just to check yourself once in a while (when you have doubts or when you are totally lost)... that’s ok... that’s exactly how I use the piano. It’s useful for that and it works fine.
Just to summarize what I think about this device:
It’s a great tuner: small, low cost, easy to use, clear, fast and it’s handy and safe to place it on your instrument. When you are looking for an accurate, fast and practical electronic tuner, this is a very good option.
As a metronome it’s limited, but it can come in handy when you are on the road or when you don’t use a metronome that often.
As a check to play in tune, the device absolutely does what it promises: the response is very quick, accurate and clear. However: use it carefully and certainly don’t use it all the time. It can help you when you use it right... it can work against you when you use it wrong.
You can buy this device in my violin shop located in Holland. Click here!
You can also buy it on Amazon.com. Click here!
Is this video helpful to you? Please let me know in the comments below! If you like it, share it with your friends!
PS: Do you have questions or struggles on violin or viola playing? Post a comment below or send an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org and I might dedicate a Violin Lounge TV episode to answering your question!
This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine