Rarities: Nathan Milstein's arrangement of 'The Seamstress'

August 29, 2017, 9:06 PM · I was in high school and was playing a recital when after a long and demanding concert I played a quiet encore: the Chopin Nocturne in C sharp minor arranged by Nathan Milstein.

In the post concert discussion with my teacher, I think he was happier with my selection of encore than with the recital itself. Then he mentioned an arrangement by Milstein that I had never heard of: the Seamstress.

I filed that in the back of my mind and continued studying his other arrangements. In the folio was not only the Chopin but the Liszt Consolation and Tchaikovsky Lullaby from Mazeppa. Milstein had recorded all three and the Liszt and the Chopin had been recorded by many other fine violinists.

Milstein’s more virtuosic arrangements, such as Paganiniana and Liszt Mephisto Waltz show up regularly in the arsenals of adventuresome virtuosi such as Ricci, Kremer and Hahn.

It is interesting to read Milstein's transcriptions and then listen to his performances. In his later recording of Paganiniana he changes some things from the printed score. Same with the Liszt Consolation. I personally didn't like the Mephisto Waltz until I heard a live recorded performance my friend George Philips had procured. Milstein added things that seemed to fill out the arrangement a little more.

In his memoirs he mentioned that he had the idea of Paganiniana for awhile. He writes:

“The idea for “Paganiniana” was in my mind for a long time, but I didn’t write it until I was in America. I needed a ten-minute piece for a recital, and I put “Paganiniana,” on the program, then forced myself to spend several nights in a row to finish the work. I was still changing it the day before the concert! It’s a horrible habit of mine to keep fussing with my own transcriptions. Sometimes you make a change and then, in the concert, you feel your fingers going somewhere else.”

He did seem to have a penchant for piano pieces. Who would think to arrange Mephisto Waltz for unaccompanied violin?

Apparently when Milstein was studying, there was little sheet music available and he would use his sisters piano music to practice. Nothing difficult...just Chopin Etudes. So of course Milstein developed a singular facility that sometimes defied violinistic logic. In his book on the violin, Boris Schwartz discusses how Milstein strove for purity of sound and used open strings and harmonics which seemed to work for him.

Nathan Milstein.

But despite the popularity of some of his other works, The Seamstress never shows up on programs. It has been in print (and remains so) since the 1990's in a volume of four Russian transcriptions from Schirmer.

He did record a version of the Seamstress in the 1930's but once again it was not identical to the arrangement published later. I assume it went through a metamorphosis of sorts. He did perform it as an encore in the later part of his career as evidenced by a review from St Louis in 1980.

In learning it I tried to follow his later intent rather than copying the earlier recording. In that recording Milstein plays everything separate as opposed to slurred. The original piano version also has this legato approach.

The arrangement is quite difficult, okay I lied....it's ridiculously hard! It's a testament to his playing ability that he could do this at the end of a program while in his late 70's and early 80's.

As I practiced. I tried to figure out how open strings or harmonics could be used to negotiate the leaps. This is the kind of piece that seems simple but the jumps are not quite what one would expect and I practiced as I tell my own students: slowly and in small sections. I worked on a couple of lines and then tried to find a better fingering, then I went to another section and found out that the fingering didn’t work with the next so back to the drawing board. Eventually, I got the entire thing and tried to build up the speed necessary to get the whirring sound of a sewing machine to come to life.

Once again, I have to thank my friend Alex Beyer for consenting to record this with me.

And a note to my students: YES, SLOW PRACTICE WORKS!

You might also like:


August 30, 2017 at 07:58 PM · Thank you for posting this! What a delightful piece. I think I like the Milstein transcription better than the original.

August 30, 2017 at 09:40 PM · To: Darwin Shen ~

As the first private Artist Pupil of the great Nathan Milstein, studying with him for over 3 & 1/2 years at his Chester Square home in London, (UK), I came to know Nathan Milstein & his wife, Therese, a refined pianist, & young adult 'children', whom he dearly cherished, quite well ... Later on in Mr. Milstein's globally acclaimed performing/recording career, spanning at least 70 years, he did more transcriptions for Solo Violin as well as for Violin & Piano ~ hense: Chopin's Nocturne in C# minor (originally for Piano) transcribed for Violin w/ Piano accompaniment, which is truly 'holy' ground as no other Violinist of his vintage, excepting Heifetz, of course, had such gifts of colour, imagination, vast knowledge of the Violin's capabilities & sixth sense of which register's to transcribe the melody and accompanying harmonic line to ~ It's impossible to describe my great violin mentor here w/ some brief comments, but Darwin Shen's courageous attempt at playing the unknown & rather hidden, "the Seamstress" of Nathan Milstein, was/is endearing and a tribute of sorts to this very remarkably gifted shadowed side of Milstein's musical career. He detested being referred to as 'a Professor', always snapping back, "I'm no Professor ~ I'm a Violinist!!" His fabled concert performing/ recording international global scale career was deliberately kept a bit less 'glitzy' due to Milstein's exquisitely pearled sense of understated taste & occasion. He truly disliked television, vis a vie, giving televised performances before TV camera's & once old me, elatedly, that, "I turned down playing the Brahms w/Bernstein in Zurich, as it was being televised! You know how I detest television, Elisabeth dear!" He was almost child-like in sharing his glee!! A man of many interests & many languages, Nathan Milstein was politik-astute & more than cultured with bowing which was uniquely his - as a fish in water, so natural was his way with the bow ~ He tortured me enough, showing me How he made the sound & never-matched smooth chording of the famed Milstein bow arm. I can go on and on, but will do in a Book to be penned in the near future ... We actually played the Double Concerto of Bach for two violins in d minor, the performance of which was truly captured in a photograph by a Deutsche Grammaphon top photographer, which I had no knowledge of until visiting Mrs. Milstein for the first time after losing her deeply loved and much admired husband .. We had become good friends and always used to take High Tea together with Mr. Milstein during a break between our 3 to 4 & even 5 hour violin tutorials ~ To say I learned much is a gross understatement! Milstein was a great natural 'teacher' who opened me to my own inherent possibilities and sculpted my playing, in both the left hand, technically, & with a Bow Arm 'transplant' from his to mine ~ I'm not exaggerating! He gave me, (an already concertising violinist on the same Violinist Roster with him), a violinistically musical "face lift" which doesn't require Botox, but consistent playing of Unaccompanied Bach, Paganinianna, Ernst's 'Der Erlkonig', Dont, Kreutzer, scales, et al (check out Andre Granat's 'The Heifetz Book of Scales'), major violin concerti, pieces + Violin & Piano Sonata repertoire & Cadenza's always to keep all well maintained ~

Please accept my Thanks, Darwin, for your curiosity & intrigue about Nathan Milstein, whom many Violinist's consider my 'other' mentor, Jascha Heifetz's, only peer!!

Please comment & if you wish, visit me on www.linkedin.com/ Elisabeth Matesky (Profile w/ email contact info, etc. )

Sending warm wishes, keep studying & work carefully on your Bowing, especially in the Lower middle, near to the Frog and smooth out your bowing changes or find a teacher who has a rounded sound with what we term, 'bow sound' ~

Yours musically from America ~

Elisabeth Matesky *

*Internationally recognised Violinist/ Master Teacher-Carrier of

the Heifetz-Milstein Legacy of Violin Playing

*Google YouTube, Jascha Heifetz Violin Master Classes,USC,

Khachaturian, JH-7, Elisabeth Matesky (*Russian version)

ASTA website: www.astaweb.com (About Elisabeth Matesky)

(c)Copyright E. Matesky 8/30/2017. All rights reserved.

This article has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.

Facebook YouTube Instagram Email

Violinist.com is made possible by...

Shar Music
Shar Music

Pirastro Strings
Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins
JR Judd Violins

Los Angeles Philharmonic
Los Angeles Philharmonic

Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra
Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

Anne Cole Violin Maker
Anne Cole Violin Maker

Violinist.com Shopping Guide
Violinist.com Shopping Guide

Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Jargar Strings

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop



Los Angeles Violin Shop


String Masters

Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine