The Joy of Teaching Violin to Adults Online
Of all the myriad things I have to do just to get by these days, the one thing that feels right and gives me comfort is picking up the instrument and doing some thing as trivial as playing a single collé using only the fingers. This is how I know, right in my core that I am a violinist. Nothing excites me more in my unexciting (!) life than just feeling the balance of a bow in my hand without even a violin there. It's just something beautiful that resonates deep inside me. (Buri the hippy strikes again!)
Since the pandemic started, I have rarely had time to practice. I have a full time job, and then I come home and teach English online in order to pay for my wife's hospital fees. Teaching English online is actually quite good fun because I meet the most amazing characters from all over the world. The platform I use basically allows people to teach anything they want at any price they like, so I decided, somewhat reluctantly, to throw dirt cheap violin lessons into the mix.
I decided to make them really cheap for the following reasons:
- I don't practice much so I can't say my demonstrations are of the highest quality.
- I was not 100% convinced that online is the best medium for me to teach because I prefer to be up really close and check people muscle use problems and the like.
- The other top teachers on this platform are highly skilled Japanese violinists who have done reasonably well in competitions and clearly know what they are doing. What right do I have to charge the same as them since they are relatively cheap anyway?
- I want people with little spare cash and the desire to learn to have some kind of access to basic lessons.
In the beginning, I was swamped by requests for English lessons, with violin students being few and far between. I think there was often a mismatch between what people seeking really cheap lessons wanted and what I was/am willing to offer. Very often, it would be something like a 'self-taught for six months, trying to play the Franck Sonata' adult. I have tremendous respect for such a student's goals and seriousness, but I am not willing to compromise on my basic teaching stance.
That is to say, for me, it is always back to basics, to the foundations. These basics are absolutely the same for the highest level soloist and the beginner. The only difference is the highest level soloist is just tuning her Ferrari engine while the beginner is trying to screw a tailpipe back on. The toolkit is the same! Thus, with every student who comes to me I explain what I am going to teach, the thinking behind it (in a nutshell: controlling a relaxed body with the mind) and how we are going to strive towards that elusive goal.
On the whole, spending a lot of time on pieces goes on the back burner, although essential musical ideas are still discussed using appropriate works for some small part of the lesson.
I know much of the available teaching resources and effective exercises for the violin, so it isn't that hard to find what works best for people. Teaching adult beginners is actually fairly new to me and the relative sameness of the problems is deeply interesting to me, especially with bowing, which I will discuss briefly below.
If bowing is the starting point, then initial lessons are always spent on using whatever resources work to get an internalized understanding of such things as:
- A natural and comfortable bow hold.
- The right hand fingers are the suspension of a car
- Understanding that bowing in a straight line is a collection of integrated curves.
- The role of the fingers on the stick.
- The relationship between speed, weight and sounding point.
- Using the smallest joints for the small bowings.
I often have to begin with pencil work so the student can see and practice the three basic directions the fingers the fingers can move the bow in. Work is then done on collé and even a feeling of this stroke within a detaché stroke of the bow change, although I have long since rejected the excessive use of finger action, which was the bog standard taught when I was at RCM way back in the beginning of time.
Playing a collé stroke at the heel followed by the middle or point and/or any sequence the student likes is a fundamental method for helping a student understand precisely what holding the bow should feel like as well as how the balance of the bow changes and a loose, relaxed arm. Balancing the bow on the violin and music stand while sliding the hand up and down the stick is one of the simplest ways to teach the curved movements of the bow arm and I add a few Sevcik Opus 2/3 wrist exercises later.
I promised not to mention the left hand which is a whole new discussion, but recently I have been using Yost for students who need work on their shifting. That in itself is no big deal, but since I keep my left hand in shape (if I have any time) by practicing everything in fifths (something I learnt from Rodney Friend many moons ago, but check out his current Youtube videos) I introduce this practice method through Yost, where it is actually extremely efficient and builds technique rapidly.
There have been a fair number of occasions when students simply don't come back, but over time the numbers have started to grow. It may be because I am learning to explain what we are doing better in an online situation, but I also feel that adults who are willing to listen and apply themselves are getting the sense of this is how I show my respect to them. I hope so, anyway.
Long time since I wrote anything, so this meandered quite a lot. Hope it was of some interest. Warmest regards,
Buri
* * *
Enjoying Violinist.com? Click here to sign up for our free, bi-weekly email newsletter. And if you've already signed up, please invite your friends! Thank you.
Tweet
Replies
This is amazing, thank you! Best wishes for improving health to your wife.
Professor Brivati,
You are a fellow online violin teacher as well as Feline Guardian - great combination.
The the description of what you teach and how you teach it is interesting and informative. Yet you did not expand on why you chose to focus on adults.
I have an adult online student that I "coach" more than teach. I find teaching adults (all late starters like myself) very satisfying. Adults are easier to talk to, understand explanations, and usually follow through on what instruction I provide.
Additionally, there is no pretense in adults dreaming of a performance career. They want to play the violin just to play the violin.
Warming up the right hand fingers with collé in different places of the bow is one of the things I learned here on violinist.com a long long time ago, from Buri! We need more of this material! All the best to you Buri, sorry to hear about your wife's medical issues.
Hi Buri, I'm so sorry your wife has to be hospitalized and wishing you all the best. Thank you for your teaching insights, as always!
I like to play along with my students. This was impossible with Zoom because of the time delay. Also I could not tell if they were playing the correct rhythym because of the time delay. I will not teach online again!
When teaching online, if I wanted my student to play with me, I would ask them to mute themselves. That took care of the delay issue. I would watch the screen like a hawk to catch fingering/note errors on their part.
Thank you for this informative (and amusing - the Cesar Franck reference) article Buri. Best wishes to you and your wife.
Loved your post, Stephen. What online platform do you use to find students? And what technology do use to teach online? I send you my best wishes for a speedy recovery for your wife and for all your efforts.
Hi Alexander. Sorry for the slow reply. I teach on Cafetalk and usually use skype although Zoom is ok.
warmest regards,
Buri
This article has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com is made possible by...
Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases
Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins
Laurie's Books
Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn
Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine
June 7, 2023 at 04:30 AM · Wonderful read Buri. I hope your wife is doing better, not just for you, but for the whole violin community!