Stephen: You have very excellent taste -- Viktoria Mullova is totally amazing!!! Wish more people appreciated her.

I agree that Mullova gives a very satisfying performance of Bach Chaconne. She makes it sound so easy, and when I listen to her I think -- "I can do that too". The feeling quickly disappears as soon as I actually try... ;)

Btw, there is a video (not just the audio recording) of Mullova performing the same piece here:

Mullova plays it in kind of a dry, stately way. Other recordings are more dug-in. I like it. I wonder if players choose a more detached style when they are in such a place as a cathedral.
Mr Brivatti, I invite you to listen to Mischa Elman in this gorgeous quality LP recording. I spend a lot of time searching for the most perfect/elegant sound/phrasing and it shows up in Thibaud, Prihoda, Enescu, Zimbalist, Seidel and probably a few others I can't remember now, but Elman never seems to lose that perfection. I have more examples of this perfection (I'll post some more if you want) but this is maybe the best example from Elman.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0wZmMLoVNDI&index=26&list=PLF9sHH6NFGJOXJwVQaqTLCWncd0RTfcsv

When I hear this my soul melts, I get shivers on my whole body and my eyes get moist. In that order in the first minute :P

Grettings
I like her chaconne a lot, but it isn't the subject of this blog;)

cheers
Buri

Fascinating selection, as usual. You may be aware that the Gitlis Bartok used to be available in a Vox 2-CD set including an equally awesome performance of the (Bartok) second concerto, along with Sibelius, Mendelssohn, a somewhat truncated Tchaikovsky and some others. I can't remember much about it except the two Bartok items which are unforgettable!
I didn't find Zimmerman's Bruch particularly 'way-out', but it's not a piece I listen to often. I enjoyed it - magnificent playing and nothing routine about it. Mullova's Bach too, although I found myself wishing she would 'let go' more at the big climaxes - it's all a little held-back for my taste (or lack of it). But the restraint pays off in so many places where others pile on the tone and the vibrato with much less discrimination. I'll investigate Szeryng.
My apologies, Buri, I put the wrong Youtube in there for you! Everyone, I've fixed it so that Mullova's accompanied Bach appears in the appropriate place, as that is what Buri is speaking about. But since I originally put her distractingly good Chaconne in there also, I left it at the end for those who would still like to discuss that! Best, Laurie
Interestingly, Oistrakh made a wonderful recording of the Bach accompanied sonatas with a harpsichord player named Paul Pischner. I got them from someone who made the recording off of LPs, and I doubt they are really available. However, if you can hear them, they are gorgeous.
Greetings,
thanks you for the Elman recommendation. Actually I have been listening to mischa, Jascha, toscha et al. for more years than I would care to say. Of the whole crew, if I really had to make a choice it would be Kreisler and later Milstein but would miss Szigeti like crazy. However, my current purpose in listening and writing is a little different.

There is no doubt that violinists do things differently now. Of course, things like modern strings, shoulder rests and competitions have all changed the type of sound we here but also perhaps how music is approached too. So the question in my mind was whether the golden age of the fiddle was dead and a step back has been taken to uniformity and bland. perfection. In seeking to answer this question I am listening to more modern players to see if they have anything to offer, whether they are individually recognizable and so on.
My personal response is a guarded yes. With some listening it is not that much more difficult to pick out Hahn, Vengerov, Bell, Kavakos, Mullova et al. And although the sound is generally less throbbing and tormented soul searching in essence , in other ways it is just as rewarding and satisfying to listen to these players as it is to the old. I also find new and interesting things that indicate an ongoing evolution in playing and sound. For example, Gringolts version of the Paginini Caprices is ground breaking and offers up new kinds of ideas for the violin. The problem is not to lose those beautiful and amazing things from the past. The sad thing is, even when I was a student, many of my fellow students had never even heard Heifetz or the young Menuhin play. And this was the RCM. I have never forgotten how weird and even tragic that seemed to me.
What I hope to do in my selections is to, in a modest way, save the reader time in finding the 'best' or perhaps just interesting version of something that is worth taking possession of.
In the same vein, I have heard Oistrakh playing the accompanied Bach, as well as Grumiaux, Szeryng and more players of that statue than I would care to name. In the cas eof Oistrakh I would never say it was anything other than superb but then everything of his is. But I think bach in general and these pieces in particular can take a very romantic violinists baroque approach and blow you away. At the same time , just for me, this is only one view of it which I find it doesn't quite meet what I feel and want. Probably Milstein would be the closest version for me of that generation but I don't have it , if it exists. To me , Oistrahks version is like a Van Gogh or Kandinsky painting. But I want something more like an exquisite stained glass window that gives that sensuality but let's through Bachs divine light. In my opinion, the result of a century of struggle and controversy over how 'real' violinists should play Bach has resulted in interpretations like that of Mullova that come closer to my ideal of what it can be.
Cheers,
Buri

Heh ... I wondered if "accompanied" was a typo but decided not to risk being a grammar troll.
Thank you, Buri. I enjoyed listening to your selections.
Our brains and bodies were pretty much the same from at least 10.000 years up to now, only the environment changed. Of course people in the past were still people and just as musical and soulful. But now the environment is different. Nobody cares for the lush sound, voice like quality, supreme sensitivity to the touch of the bow that gut strings provide. People just want a big sound to fill the hall. They don't want to put too much effort in maintenance and bowing technique other than staccato or riccochet or whatnot because they have so much left hand technique to worry about, let alone tweaking the timing that Elman does so beautifully, why would you tweak the timing? Touching souls with music can't be more important than perfect rhythm, right?. If you can't play Paganini nowadays you are worthless. People listen to Elman and say he's outdated, his slides are weird, timing is wrong, intonation is off (I'm not sure about this one but it's said about other old players) and somehow the beauty just foregoes them. It's unbelievable. They are right about one thing; it's outdated. When I heard that recording of Elman I was pinching myself, not believing that it was real, it was more beautiful than anything I had ever imagined. Also people put the shoulder "crutch" on as if it has no impact. If you fail to realise how much the shoulder rest impairs movement and sound you simply fail as an artist in my opinion. People think that Huberman is simply a strange mediocre player. I would be hard pressed to name 5 violinists that can play nearly as beautifully as him.

Here are two korean (?) young ladies playing with as much soul as you would want, this is one of the exceptions. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hultf4cdOXk

This young lady is another extraordinary exception https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuJo36h7UkQ

Here is some from the good old people :) Don't forget to put it on the highest quality, it makes a big difference:

An explosion of color by Zimbalist and Sarasate

Perhaps my favorite Menuhin recording

It's said that Casals called him the greatest musical phenomenon since Mozart

This made me fall in love with high quality LP recordings

Enescu playing Mozart's 7th VC

I know that posting so much at once makes it highly unlikely that you'll listen to all of them, but I'm an idiot that way. I just can't leave one of them out :P

I think looking for reasons to see say the old were just as good as the new is like rationalizing religion. That is using twisted logic to make observed reality match your beliefs instead of being honest.

Greetings,
actually the 'the great leap forward,' theory that holds human evolution more or less stopped forty thousand years ago is being increasingly challenged by many scientists and researchers. There are innumerable genetic changes in recent times including things like malaria resistance, blue eyes, lactose tolerance and so on. The IQ test is an interesting case. In terms of simple statistics, today's average human scores significantly higher than for example 100 years ago. That is why IQ test have been adjusted so that we don't have the embarrassing problem of the least intelligent in our society scoring higher than Winston Churchill, which would actually happen. A close look at this weird phenomenon show the skewing occurs becaus ewe score substantially higher on things like human empathy and compassion these days. Thus it was much more normal for countries to condone and go to war in the early part of the 20 C than it is now, blips aside. For a detailed explanation of this see Pinkers book, the Angel inside us, or something like that... I have an IQ problem at this time in the morning.
As for the rest I am non shoulder rest using devotee of violinists of the past so I am not entirely sure why you are preaching to the converted;) There is no doubt about the quality of Elmans playing and the suggestion he played out of tune is just silly. The clips offered as following in his footsteps are lovely but really not that great after a while. Hardly in the same class as elman.Huberman is a little more complex because he wasn't entirely able to embrace and join in with the sea change that elman wa sin part responsible for. At his best he is sublime. On occasion he can sound less than interesting. I have most of his recordings and listen to them a lot.
But to dismiss modern players is , in my opinion simply to express a prejudice as deep as those who say older players are no good. I ask my students to listen to everything and make up their own minds. personally I cannot say, for example , that vengerov playing a Handel sonata is less musical or profound than Szigeti and the sound quality is certainly better.
In the end it boils down to personal preference. Personally, I weep and shudder at tsunamis and mans inhumanity to man. I feel deep pleasure and satisfaction listening to elman et al. Then I might go and brush my teeth or take a dump. what we want to take from music I think is up to the individual and cannot be imposed on others. The only important thing is to keep an open mind and try everything.
Cheers,
Buri
It's no use getting a heated discussion about old vs new, because maybe it really does boil down to personal opinion, I don't know. You should know that I'm eternally grateful for these modern players that I can inferior to the old masters because they are still musicians. And they still touch the souls of so many millions of people, showing them that life is not always mundane, giving them a moment of euphoria. Many top soloists probably make more people happy in a single concert than I will in an entire lifetime. I feel a bit phony talking like this but I just wanted to share it.

Cheers, and keep playing people!! :)

Isn"t it so that most people forced to accept one side of the issue will become strong supporters of that side? You seldom hear a Strad player denigrate their instrument or wish they could get hold of a good modern. Good instruments are rare, antique OR modern . . .

Violinist.com is made possible by...

Shar Music

Pirastro Strings

JR Judd Violins

Los Angeles Philharmonic

Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra

Dimitri Musafia, Master Maker of Violin and Viola Cases

Anne Cole Violin Maker

Violinist.com Shopping Guide

Metzler Violin Shop

Southwest Strings

Bobelock Cases

Johnson String Instrument/Carriage House Violins

Jargar Strings

Bay Fine Strings Violin Shop

FiddlerShop

Fiddlerman.com

Los Angeles Violin Shop

Baerenreiter

String Masters

Nazareth Gevorkian Violins

Laurie's Books

Discover the best of Violinist.com in these collections of editor Laurie Niles' exclusive interviews.

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 1, with introduction by Hilary Hahn

Violinist.com Interviews Volume 2, with introduction by Rachel Barton Pine

Subscribe