Rosin and Bow matching?
Sorry if the question is dumb. I have read many threads about different results when combining a particular rosin to a particular brand of strings. I would like to ask if in the same spirit is there any variability in the rosin and bow matching, such as that given a particular set of violin, strings and some bows, one would get different preferences of rosin in different bows.
If that is the case, is it a regular practice to dedicate a particular rosin to a particular bow? or once found the best rosin for the strings it is the one used for all bows?
Rosin thread! Oh boy!! I've certainly heard of people using different rosin for violin vs. viola (although I use the same -- Bernardel), but not different violin bows. But like everything in the violin world, I'm sure there are those who do this.
If there is considerable difference in horse hair, seems it only right to find the best rosin for type used. Bow hair comes from all kinds of sources; from cold vs warm climates, male vs female hair, synthetic vs real, mane vs tail, white vs color, bleached vs natural. Violinists and luthiers can get exceptionally picky about the hair quality, seems to reason getting picky about how the particular type of hair reacts to the rosin on it will eventually come into play. If you're splitting hairs...
imho, more to do with strings. I tend to pick bows that go with an instrument, each time I change types of strings, then match the rosin, repeat.
I have found that which rosin I choose to use does make a difference, as do the strings I use and the bow I use. But I have not found a need to match bow hair and rosin. I have also found a link between rosin choice and weather (temperature for sure/humidity perhaps). I suspect the state of my hearing also influences my preference for one rosin compared to another.
They ought to match in colour.
I have found it useful to use different rosins in different seasons (I’m in Canada).....but above that I haven’t given it that much more thought!
@Andrew: You have guessed my problem. The issue I am having is that when I start daily practice the room is at about 80% humidity. I switch on the air conditioning and in about a couple of hours the humidity has gone down quite significantly and I am noticing that in the "grip" of the rosin I use. It starts great with high humidity but as the humidity goes down (more significantly than temperature) another bow, a worse one that uses a cheaper rosin, becomes better than the more expensive with the better rosin and I have to switch. That led me to wonder if others had similar circumstances such as preferring a certain rosin for light bows with low voice but a different one for others and to adapt them to how tired you are or something like that. From what I am reading it does not seem to be a regular practice so I will look for a less sensitive or more balanced rosin to use.
I also switch by season. Currently, Millant Dark and Jade for vln/vla, Guillaume & Jade for cello, Carllson & Nyman for bass. I was an Andrea guy when I played on Pirastros on vln/vla before switching to Kaplans. I use the same on my pernambuco and carbon bows for all instruments. I often use carbon in larger ensembles and when I’m switching back and forth to ease transitions in doubling, but prefer wood for most other playing.
I find my “happy medium” rosin during the fall when the humidity really starts to go down is Pirastro Oliv:Evah (I use Passione strings typically with obligato E through out the year) and everything seems to wake up after the season change when using this regardless of what bow I use.
This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses.