Can one be allergic to one kind of rosin?
On my earlier post, I was discussing about melting and mixing rosins. Well, I did just that. It was a success! After using it for a while now, I had gotten some rosin powder into my eye after it snagged on my fine tuner (quite normal for me), and uh clearly it was uncomfortable. I rinsed it out and was fine. That was with mixed rosin. Then I accidentally did that again today, in which it was pure black rosin. I did exactly the same thing and rinsed my eye, but a couple minutes later my eye was sort of red. Nothing serious but I was wondering if one could be allergic to some kind of rosin.
Some people have various reactions to rosin and rosin dust.
Getting rosin in your eyes is "normal for you"? That sounds very strange. It's quite possible that different amounts of rosin got into your eye on the two different occasions, or into different parts of your eye, or that you rubbed your eye differently. I wouldn't jump to conclusions about differential allergy.
Probably no more than irritation from the rosin. If you were allergic to it you would have some weird effects like a good amount of swelling and possibly hives. Be nice to your eyes, you only have two. If there should be a next time, rinse your eyes with luke-warm water and let them tear up as much as they like. Don't rub them.
Your eye getting red after having gotten rosin in it is perfectly normal. Your eye has reacted just as if you got a hair or a bit of dust or dirt in it. One can be allergic to rosin. Customers have related sneezing, wheezing, contact dermatitis on the hands, ect.
On re-reading your post, I echo Paul in wondering how you're getting Rosin in your eye on a regular basis.
Last year I was practicing very long notes. Looking at where the bow met the string was a bad idea. I got dust in my eye and couldn't look at anything for 2 days! I look away now.
The only* rosin that ever bother me (itchy eyes) was Pirastro Goldflex. Would that qualify as being allergic to one type of rosin? I could get away with using it on cello - but not on chin instruments.
Rosin can cause allergies without direct contact such as sneezing, itching, and red eyes. However, getting rosin directly in they eye would be irritating to anyone, sans allergy. I wouldn't consider it a definite allergy since you had direct eye contact, just an irritation.
You could poke your eyes and it would be red but it would probably mean your eyes have gone through a physical distress rather than them being allergic to fingers.
@ everyone who asks me why I get rosin a lot, is because I'm an intern that helps little kids play, and they often times overosin (I don't think that's a word) and powder comes flying around like smoke on a rather daily basis. . That's where I get most rosin into my eyes, but ususally in my own practice, it happens only once in a while.
Yes, different types of rosin certainly trigger reactions (allergic or otherwise) to different degrees. Like Clarity synthetic, Magic Rosin is also far less triggering than some/most others, and it's stickier than Clarity. Get the kids to use Magic (and use less) if it's bothering you and you can -- they also come with cute pictures. Some brands are also dustier than others -- I remember Melos dark bothering me so much that I couldn't use it, but don't find Bernardel to be irritating.