Platinum e with PI strings
Can anyone tell me their experience with the platinum e string with the PI strings or have they found an alternative e string they like to go with the other PIs?
Are you using the strings right now? Before a few years I got the set with the platinum E. Well, it's an E string that costs around 20 dollars/euros . It was nice but it did not made THAT huge difference (to me). I used it also with Eudoxa plain steel E, Gold Label E and the Dominant E (I sometimes like it in a particular instrument) All of them seemed ok to me. Also as far as I know, the PI set comes with 3 different E options, platinum, gold and tin.
I love the PI platinum E string. I have used it with PI sets, Vision Solo sets, and Evah Pirazzi Gold sets. I have used this E on 4 different violins and have found that THIS E improves the sound of the other strings compared to other E strings I have used on them with similar sets over the past decades.
I'm going to warn you that opinions on strings are highly controversial because
Andrew - it would be interesting to hear your opinion on the new Pirastro platinum E compared to the PI. I have also found that the Pirastro platinum E improved the other strings, but I never tried the PI. At least here in Europe the Pirastro is significantly cheaper.
I do like the e, but its always a bit harsh around fith position. The Pi now dropped to the Pirastro price at some suppliers, I havent tested the Pirastro yet.
platinum it is then
Full set of PI with the plat E for me. I change the whole set every three months.
You play the e as long as the rest?
Really has to do with which one of you plays longer every day, doesn't it??
In total yes, but relative to each other is what I wonder. The e string goes of quicker than the rest off the set for me.
I change my E once a month with a variety of different brands because I think it makes the lower strings sound better and that is the main reason why I am reluctant to spend $30 on a platinum E. On the other hand, if the Platinum E does last longer it would be worth it to me. Would Heifitz be using this string?
Well, it's not a fair question to ask, as the Master was probably not one to easily change his ways. "Goldbrokat 26 only" would have likely been his answer (I find it funny how Optima brand markets these as the "Original Heifetz String.") To his defense-as if he needed any-it's an incredible option, and matches the strings he used to use quite marvelously.
I was surprised to hear that some people change the E string more frequently than the other strings. I've changed the Goldbrokat E string twice in the last 4 years.
It's dependent upon the corrosive qualities of your perspiration. Some E strings may resist your particular chemistry better than others. I used Jaeger E strings on a previous violin of mine, for instance, but they'd tarnish within 2 to 4 weeks, going false. From that perspective, the PI platinum E string, which would be fine for 6 months, was a good deal.
There is no generalisation between amateur and professional in this matter.
I typically go through 2 E strings for every 1 set of A-D-G strings. I like the PI Platinum E, but the Goldbrokat Optima seems to work just as well on my instruments. The platinum E did last as long as the other PI strings, I found, but the price difference still doesn't justify it for me. I picked up an EP Platinum E to try out with the next set of PIs, so we'll see how that goes.
At my last check up, my violin shop suggested the Jargar E with the rest of the PI set. I think the Jargar is higher tension, but it made a noticeable difference with improving the punch of the e string. I just installed a new set and just kept all the strings PI (felt wasteful to not use the PI E), and have really noticed the change. I will probably replace with a Jargar soon, and see what how the price of the GDA compares with the whole set. This was with the tin E, but I haven't really noticed that the platinum E was a big step up.
The Jagar is a bit more powerfull if the violin can stand the tension and it fits the PI in my opinion. For my violin its a bit of an overkill, the violin is already very loud. If I play without earplugs my left ear is stressed even hours after playing.
I'm using the Warchal Steel A and special E (the spiral one) with PI D & G and love the results I get. The whole instrument seems better balanced.
The Warchal steel A and anti whistle E has interested me for a while. Do you have a fine tuner for the A string Malcolm?
I've been using mostly the Vision solo strings along with the Pirastro E string.