Best Oliv A string substitute?
About a year ago, I switched from Peter Infeld to High tension Olivs, and have never looked back. However, although I adore the entire Oliv set, the A string has proven to be especially annoying. It's not even about the tuning problems or the tone quality, those I can deal with, but the longevity of it. In a matter of half a year, I went through about three Oliv As due to the winding unraveling; the last one of which unraveled even before tone started to stabilize.
I don't think it has anything to do with the set up of the violin, as no other string I have used behaved like this.
I have tried to use other strings with mixed success, like the Eudoxa A and even the Tricolore A, which I liked quite a lot, but did not mix well with the rest of the Olivs.
I have the Eudoxa A on at the moment, but really don't like the tone of it...
Any recommendation would be appreciated!
...just a quick question. when you say 'high tension Olivs, do you mean heavy gauge as opposed to medium?
Yes, I mean the heavy gauge. Since I came from synthetics like most players, I'm not quite used to the gauges of gut strings...
I've had the same problem with the Oliv A string unwinding - it's even happened straight out of the envelope. Never had that problem with any other A string (and I happen to like the sound of the Oliv A, but what's the point?). One substitute is the Passione A. That should work, but I wish they would solve the Oliv A problem...
Where does the string start to unravel?
I currently use Passione Solo A with Oliv silver D and rigid G. That works for me. Non-gut alternatives are Aricore-Eudoxa and Warchal Amber. I have the same experience you did with the Oliv A. Good sound, but never became stable like the D and G before unraveling.
I used Olives for a while and tho7ght they were the best strings for my instrument but the A was frustrating and eventually I moved on. At that time the idea to try a separate A string had never occurred to me . I have been considering trying. Olive G and D again with one of the Warchal steel A strings but now they are so expensive.
After all the negative reviews I've read, I've so far avoided the Oliv A. I have used Oliv stiff D-G more than once on my 1883 instrument -- plus Eudoxa A, which OP currently uses.
Chao, what if you try bringing the Oliv A up to pitch very slowly when installing it - maybe even over a few hours? I wonder if that might help to preserve the winding.
Hey Martin, it has unwound at the nut (right out of the envelope) and, over a week or so, it will start at the bridge. I really don't think there was a problem at the nut - in fact, I had a very well regarded luthier install a brand new Oliv A for me to see what would happen and if he could figure it out. It unwound, and he couldn't say it was the nut's fault. Nutty, right?