Electric 5 string vs. 4 stringInstruments: Pros and cons of a 5 string electric violin vs. 4 strings
From Jeffrey Schmitt
The question: Is it worth getting a 5 string electric or just stick with 4 strings? How much adjustement is there between going from 4 strings to 5? (That is, if she practices a classical piece on the 5 string electric will it mess her up to transition over to the 4 string acoustic violin.) Does the extended range come in handy very often? Any other pros or cons?
Thanks in advance.
From Alex YauJeffrey,
Posted on April 2, 2005 at 02:36 AM
A 5-string electric can be very helpful as for range, but in my experience, is also significantly heavier than their 4-string counterparts. My personal taste would be to stick to a 4 string, but everyone has their different preferences!
From Jenni ThompsonIf she likes lower instruments like viola and cello, I'd say definitely go for the 5 string. If not... she can probably do without. :)
Posted on April 2, 2005 at 05:23 AM
I'm 18 and looking into getting an electric, mostly to record songs I'm composing that I'd to like a "different" sound. An electric that is 4 strings can be a difference of $200 compared to 5, but after I tried a 5 string, I just couldn't imagine getting one without that lovely, deep C string. To get an electric that's only 4 wouldn't be worth it to me. But I think if she is only going to have one to play around with and practice on with headphones, five strings aren't at all necessary, and it won't be found lacking. Also, "heavy" would never be a word I'd use for any electric violins I've tried. The five string electrics I've played on were considerably lighter than my four string regular violin. I can't imagine, with all the small shapes electric violins come in now, that your daughter would find them heavy. Take care!
From DJ CheekJenni,
Posted on April 3, 2005 at 02:33 AM
If you like the "lovely, deep C string", then ditch the violin and become a violist.
Also, what was that Heifetz thing about???
From Jessica ParsonsJeffery,
Posted on April 4, 2005 at 03:19 AM
I recently purchased a Ned Steinburger 5-string violin, because I was asked to do some work with local bands. I too was debating between a 4-string and 5-string. I experimented with both, but decided I liked the range the 5-string had to offer, and I loved the deep, rich tones of the C string. Beware though...it's quite a bit different than playing a standard violin. I'm not sure if this applies to all electric 5-string models, but my fingerboard is quite a bit wider, because there needs to be extra room for the additional string. Also, the strings are spaced slightly closer together. I've realized that I can't relate the 5-string and my regular violin, because there are so many differences between the two. I have to see them as two completely different instruments. I am very happy with the dicision I made of getting the 5-string instead of the 4-string, but the 5-string is used only for genres other than classical. Good luck with your search! -Jess
Hear more from the world's top violinists in The Violinist.com Interviews: Volume 1, which includes our exclusive conversations with Joshua Bell, Sarah Chang, and David Garrett, and others, as well as a foreword by Hilary Hahn.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!