Setting up a violin - questionsInstruments: I was given an old 3/4 violin; I'm told it will cost more than the instrument is worth to fix it up. Can I do it myself?
From Rae-ann Heinrich
2) The pegs on the instrument are mis-matched and not great. If I buy a set of ebony pegs on ebay, what should I know first and will I be able to fit them?
3) Is there anything wrong with using 4/4 strings on a 3/4 instrument?
Thanks in advance for any guidance.
From Lyle ReedyCan you do it yourself? Sure. Will it be a decent job? Obviously not. A bridge that has not been fitted will sort of work, but pegs HAVE to be fitted. For that you need pegs that are sufficiently oversize, a reamer to true up the holes (assuming the holes aren't already too big) and a peg shaver to make the pegs fit the holes. Then you need quite a bit of practice using the tools. Much better to find somebody who already knows all this and will do what is needed at a reasonable cost. I work on too many that have been made worse by such "fixing."
Posted on June 28, 2012 at 09:16 PM
Nothing wrong with using 4/4 strings on a 3/4. That is my standard practice.
From Marsha WeaverOh, great -- here we go again with the anti-Chinese rant. Get over it, Lyndon.
Posted on June 29, 2012 at 11:33 AM
Both of my violins are 3/4 size -- I use a 4/4 E string because the brand of E that I use (Pirastro) doesn't make a 3/4. It works fine. The other 3 strings (Dominant) do come in 3/4, so that's what I use for the G, D and A. But Lyle seems to have had success using all 4/4's on a 3/4 instrument, so heck -- go for it.
I watched my luthier fit a set of pegs once -- not something I'd want to attempt myself. You do need special tools and expertise.
It seems to me that using a 4/4 bridge on a 3/4 instrument could put the strings in sort of strange alignment with the rest of the instrument. This is just supposition on my part, though -- someone with experience on this want to weigh in? But just shponking on any old 3/4 bridge straight from the mailbox isn't going to be the answer either -- bridges should be fit (cut and ground thinner) to the individual requirements of the instrument they'll be used on.
If your grandson is considering studying the violin, it'll help him SO much if the instrument is set up to it's full potential. As long as there aren't any structural problems (crooked neck, fingerboard flaws, major cracks, etc.), and since the violin was given to you, it would probably be OK to sink a little money into it to get him off to a good start.
From John CaddCheaper than a new bike to fix everything . If you leave all your electric goods on standby for a year it costs about £85. Lots of ways to look at the finances . If he is practising he won`t be spending money doing something else . Give him the gift of music without thought for your reward . Be altruistic . He`s family .
Posted on June 29, 2012 at 02:22 PM
From Marsha WeaverNo, Lyndon. I'm simply going back to your comments about all Chinese violins being the equivalent of junk (or words to that effect). Now you bring human rights into the mix. Is this the rant of the week? :)
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 02:19 AM
From Joyce LinRae-ann, if you give a violin with ill-fitted bridge and pegs to your grandson, you are not giving him a fair chance to decide if he likes the violin. I'd say don't do it yourself!
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 02:40 AM
Lyndon, just because Chinese labor is cheap doesn't mean they are working under inhumane conditions. It's true that the average Chinese worker's standard of living is lower than the West, but if you have ever been to China, you will find that most people (at least in the cities and towns I have visited) are living quite decently. The disparity in prices between Chinese goods and the West is largely due to low cost of living, and that the Chinese government keeps the value of the RMB artificially low..
The average Chinese works 40-hour week, as regulated by the government. Factory workers and other non-professional jobs receive overtime pays if exceeding that limit, just like in the West.
(This is coming from someone who grew up in Taiwan, so you can hardly call me pro-China.)
From Roland GarrisonCome on, children! Let's get back to answering the question!
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 02:44 AM
I think the short version of the answer is already provided. You will probably not do an adequate job of setting it up.
There is a better answer, which is also true.
If you do this, even if the instrument is unplayable when you are done, at least you know a lot more about what the process entails!
From Benedict GomezSlavery? Methinks he doth protest too much.
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 03:02 AM
From Skylar NguyenJoyce-
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 03:07 AM
I'm not defending Lyndon, but there are many place that's still under condition like that in China, Taiwan is relatively far off the true China, which is someplace you not only have to visit but also have to speak the languages and willingly sleep on an infested cot to understand to. China isn't a pretty place.
I AM NOT DEFENDING LYNDON, JUST GIVING FACT THAT I SAW AND EXPERIENCES THROUGH JOURNALISM INTERN.
oh and Joyce, is there by any chance the town and city you visited are a part of your tour? Because if it is, then you're far from the truth.
From Joyce LinSkylar, I was not talking about Taiwan, which is more well-off than most European countries...
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 03:13 AM
I've been visiting China since 1994 (and most recently in 2010). I can tell you that their standard of living has improved tremendously since the 1990s, and most people in the cities live a middle-class life style. However, I'm aware of social issues such as rural-urban divide and income inequality - these are nothing new in the West, just not as magnified...
I didn't travel with tour groups. Since I speak the language and can pass as a local (not always successfully), I took public transportation whenever possible... And I have worked with locals (granted these are not low-pay laborers), and been invited to their homes, so I have a fairly good idea what average people live like, at least in cities like Shanghai, Beijing, and other more developed areas.
Most of Chinese violins are made in a village near Beijing and towns in southern China (Jiangsu and Guangdong provinces - the richest parts of China), so it's pretty safe to say that your Chinese violins are not made by starving slave labor. According to this report:
From John CaddBack to the question. To do it yourself you will need the right tools (reamers and pegcutters ).Then get the positions of post, bridge etc right to make it sound right .He will be a lot older by then . Take a chance and get the luthier to sort it out in one day. Costing more than it`s worth (??) when you got it free is a conundrum . Badly fitted pegs will be a huge discouragement to a young player . Get your luthier to fix it . Then we can all get back to fighting about World History . What a lot of fighting going on in this forum lately .
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 01:44 PM
From Marsha WeaverWell-said, John. Sorry I joined the melee, but just got tired of the constant bashing of Chinese violins (and new violins, and under-$1000 violins). I've had one Chinese violin that was unplayable, and now have one that I really love. I just want to see each judged on its own merit. I'll try to behave. ;)
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 03:12 PM
From Joyce LinEh, was I in a fight?! Why did I not notice?! :) I was just trying to address some misconceptions here, albeit off-topic... I hope my posts are at least educational to some. Sorry to the OP (but I think she has gotten lots of good answers already)!
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 06:38 PM
From John CaddNo Joyce , the fighting is mostly on other topics . Plenty to choose from .
Posted on June 30, 2012 at 08:34 PM
From Skylar Nguyen
Posted on July 1, 2012 at 01:08 AM
From Joyce LinSkylar, my understanding is that it means RMB$800 (yuan), not US$800. In the link earlier in the same paragraph (the YouTube video) - it said that "the workers earn around 1,000 to 2,000 yuan (150 to 300 U.S. dollars) a month," so I thought it's pretty obvious... Anyway, how much their income is equivalent to the US dollars is irrelevant! The main point in the quote is that earning 800 yuan (~US$126) per month in that village as a violin-maker is a solid middle-class income. (The definition of middle-class here is: "having a reasonable amount of discretionary income, so that they do not live from hand to mouth as the poor do.")
Posted on July 1, 2012 at 02:27 AM
Also, it seems that you either have trouble understanding my posts, or you need to look up the map and see where Taiwan is. I only brought up my Taiwanese heritage to make the point that I would be the last person on this forum to speak in favor of the Chinese government and fall for their propaganda (Read about modern Chinese history if you don't know what I'm talking about)... I try to present unbiased personal accounts and the information that I believe to be factual (judging from my experience, of course). It's very rude of you to attack my credibility before you are able to read and comprehend my posts and the information I put forth!
It's funny that you call cities "STAGED PLACE FOR FOREIGNER" - are you still living in the China of the 1970s-80s? Have you ever been to China lately? True, I have never visited poor remote villages, and I'm aware of the many social issues that China faces, including poverty in the rural (and to a lesser extent, urban) areas. I never said China is perfect, did I? It still has a long way to go, but it has come a long way since the '90s, as I'm a witness...
All I was trying to say was that Chinese violins, which, by the way, are made in the "developed" (more precisely - developing) regions, are not made by slave labor. Prove me wrong if you can, but save the personal attacks and the tone!
From Skylar NguyenOh dear, my apology Joyce, I was under my uncle influences when I wrote the post. At least you could have mention the Yuan part.
Posted on July 1, 2012 at 05:07 AM
Anyway, I'll excuse myself from this topic now. In prevention of my mouth flying off again.
From John CaddMy Dad went up the Yangtse River in the Navy a long time ago . He always told us off if we wasted any food. Not very likely in 1950s postwar England . "The starving Chinese would be glad of that " was his constant phrase. Also useful background is the record on Wikipedia of the Nanking Massacre . I imagine they remember horrors that were forced on them just as we remember the Spanish Armada or the Blitz . (Look up Blitz too ) . Even England has to hang it`s head in shame for inventing a Concentration Camp in South Africa in the Boer War .
Posted on July 1, 2012 at 02:19 PM
Maybe the Chinese are like Spiders. More afraid of us than we are of them .
We should seek out ways to be more sympathetic internationally . The world can only get better or far worse than we ever imagined . Not much chance of staying exactly the same .
From Roland GarrisonWell said, John. I've always felt that what we fear defines us more than it defines the object of our fears. Today's political rhetoric on all sides seems to support that (Not only US, but internationally).
Posted on July 1, 2012 at 04:51 PM
From John CaddI feel uncomfortable lately with David Cameron saying almost casual insults about Greece. A politician can unravel years of history and rekindle all sorts of old hostility that had been left behind . Other countries are like next door neighbours. You can never be too careful . Something else annoyed me this week. It may have been an announcer this time referring to Spain and Italy "on the --periphery--of Europe". What planet is he on ?? They are bang in the middle of my mental image of Europe . Periphery ?
Posted on July 2, 2012 at 04:25 PM
No ,get the pegs done for you . (btw ).
From Rae-ann HeinrichWow! I love where this thread wound up!! But anyway, thanks for all the good info. I am going to just try messing around with this little guy and what I especially like about it is that I don't have to worry about how he handles the instrument. It does have problems with the fingerboard and the neck --the shape, thickness and angle! He likes the idea of having his own violin (even tho it is still too big for him) and I'll just wait to see if he begins to agitate for lessons before getting a 'real' violin for him.
Posted on July 2, 2012 at 04:51 PM
(Another interesting thing is that even though it traveled overseas with no bridge, and no case, the sound post is still in place. At this point, however, I can't worry about sound post adjustments!)
From Smiley HsuLyndon,
Posted on July 2, 2012 at 07:48 PM
While it is true that there are some really junky Chinese violins, the ones in the $1000-$3000 price range are very compelling. I have played Chinese violins under $2000 that sound and play very nicely. I would even say that if you have less than $3000 to spend on a violin, and you want the best bang for your buck, you should focus your search on Chinese instruments.
From John CaddI like the idea of Lyndon`s part of the violin sector. Is that the right word ? He deals with lots of violin history . Each instrument has a story or a mystery attached . Good luck with that .
Posted on July 2, 2012 at 08:00 PM
From Roland GarrisonI say go for it, but don't measure the task by the quality of instrument you end up with.
Posted on July 3, 2012 at 05:42 AM
I have a little guy I spend a lot of time with (9 year old grandson with Aspergers). Since we are so close, I got him a 1/4 violin a couple years ago, in the white. Spent a bit of time sanding, smoothing (I no nothing about graduating, so I didn't try), and spent about as much time or more on the finish. Sides and back were stained with about 8 or 10 layers of my own mix (mineral spirit and linseed oil, with varying colors and saturations of oil-based pigments). The front was his favorite color; red. That was the tough part; getting a good red stain without using Cadmium-based stain.
Would I do it again? In a heartbeat! It was fun, and he enjoyed getting it.
From Nicky Paxton@ Rae-ann, I'm so glad that you have overcome the difficulty about setting up this violin. When I read that you had been told the cost of the set-up would exceed the violin's value, I feared that you might be in for the problem situation of having, ultra-tactfully, to give it back to the donor. (Not possible to dispose of it otherwise: donors of such things tend to ask where they have got to or want to see them in use.) However, I'm very happy to read that you have sorted things out and are getting the violin working.
Posted on July 3, 2012 at 11:51 AM
From Rae-ann HeinrichHi again,
Posted on July 3, 2012 at 08:02 PM
So, in case you're interested, the violin actually traveled from Greece to NY, (sans bridge) to get to me; returning it to the giver was not even an option since paying more shipping costs didn't seem to make much sense. Its history as far back as I know is that it was given to the daughter of a Greek friend by a friend of her mother's, probably 25 - 30 years ago, in the same condition then as it's in now. At that time, in Paris, I'm told it would have cost them the equivalent of about $100 to fix but they didn't do it since the intended recipient showed no interest in playing. It's clearly an old violin and I kind of like it... but not enough to sink any serious money into it--having been told it wouldn't be worth it. Having said that, I really dislike having objects around that are in need of fixing up so I've gone ahead and ordered a 3/4 bridge and a set of ebony pegs, on ebay. Even the way it is before the new bridge and pegs, it doesn't sound terrible -- it actually has a nice warm sound. I've heard a lot worse from fractional sized instruments. And... I'm really liking the idea of the "do-it-yourself" approach, but only under these circumstances. I would NEVER attempt to do it on a serious instrument.
From Rae-ann HeinrichWhich, of course, brings me next to getting a bow. Any suggestions on internet (ebay?) options for an inexpensive but fairly decent 3/4 bow?
Posted on July 3, 2012 at 08:03 PM
From John CaddHere`s a good site to fill in the gaps and cover some useful jobs. [ www.platetuning.org. ] It`s a good general info site . It gives lots of leads to other sites for most violin questions .
Posted on July 5, 2012 at 11:02 PM
From Gillian FrederickI was reading this thread and I just wanted to saw that you don't need special tools to shape pegs. Those tools are expensive and hard to come by. I recently started restoring a violin, I got new pegs off ebay and all you have to do to shape them is to use sand paper and twist it in your hand, (like you are sharpening a pencil) it takes some time, but it works just as well. Of course, you still have to drill the holes, but that's something else.
Posted on August 9, 2012 at 08:41 PM
Hear more from the world's top violinists in The Violinist.com Interviews: Volume 1, which includes our exclusive conversations with Joshua Bell, Sarah Chang, and David Garrett, and others, as well as a foreword by Hilary Hahn.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!