From dick de graaff
Posted July 13, 2011 at 06:34 PM
a time ago I came across a very nice unlabelled violin apparently very old. it could be Italian, made by a member of the Gagliano family, but I am a violin player and miss the knowledge to discover the origins of this instrument. It has a beautiful sound, rich amount of overtones, bright, clear and powerful tone. That's the reason why I would like to invite you and try to find an answer to this question...
What makes you think this fiddle could be a Galiano? It's hard to get a fix on this one, but something about the color of the varnish says "not 18th century Italian" to me. The F-holes are kind of funky.
Any other opinions out there?
Do you have more pictures?
Looks like 20th century to me. F holes are amateurish. Is the neck crooked?
This does not look like a violin from a distinguished maker, and the f-holes and scroll is very unconventional. But if the violin has a beautiful sound and responds well, why worry. What is in a name, only money.
With the caveat that I have no luthier expertise at all, the purfling looks a bit what my daughter would label "sketchy." It is always important to keep in mind that a violin without any label is likely not to be very valuable or by a well-known maker. AT least that is the assumption I would work with. If you really care, take it to a luthier with some expertise, or post some more pics from different angles and see if the luthiers on the site have an opinion. If it sounds great, don't worry, be happy. Finding a violin that sounds great that does not run you significant four figures is not easy.
Thanks for all answers! The sound of this violin is really exeptional, that's why I would like to know more about its origin. Its playabitiy reminds me of that of an old Italian violin, a Gagliano which I have tried shortly a long time ago. Please look carefully at the pictures below:
Picture 1 (scroll) : oi55.tinypic.com/2akkc3o.jpg
Picture 2 (Back): i51.tinypic.com/11hrl8o.jpg
Here an 18th century violin, listed as a Nicola Gagliano
Play it and enjoy it.
I think you just have a modern violin that sounds good, be happy
thanks, I will
Neck looks straight on the view of the back.
Agree , if the violin sounds exceptional and you didn't pay too much you're a lucky man and enjoy.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!