Broken finger recoveryHealth: What is your experience?
From Karen Johnson
From Bilbo PrattleMy 9yo son broke the middle phalange of his left pinkie about 2 months ago (left pinkie, a fracture, not a messy break).
Posted on March 18, 2007 at 08:41 PM
He couldn't play 4th finger for close to a month, but he is essentially fully recovered.
Two weeks ago, he fractured the ring finger outermost phalange. So now, he has pain with the 3rd finger. It bothered him too much at one week to play more than a few minutes, but today he played about an hour and had only minor pain.
In both caes, we wasted $250 for the "surgical procdure" of the doctor bending a splint, and another $120 each time for x-rays. We also followed up the 1st break at 6 weeks.
By the way, it has been very difficult keeping him wearing the splint. Maybe that's a good thing in his case--kept his soft tissues strong. Perhaps the severity or extent of the fracture dictates this aspect.
There hasn't been a need for therapy.
The thing about fingers is that they get fractured quite frequently and usually heal themselves. Unless it is a crushed mess or a tendon insertion torn off or something else gruesome, it seems that they just get better from usage.
My wife broke her pinky just doing daily stuff (10 years ago) and it points slightly differently but has had no ill effects on usage. She didn't do anything for it at the time and only later during a routine visit did a doctor say, "yeah, looks like you broke it. No big deal."
I'm pretty sure I fractured my pinky toe last year walking by the the foot of a blanket chest. I lost the toenail too. It hurt like ^^%y h%ll for a couple weeks but doesn't bother me at all any more.
From Megan ChapelasA minor fracture shouldn't be too much to worry about. I fell on my left fourth finger when I was 12 or 13 and fractured it. The doctor's advice was to tape it to my third finger, avoid bending it, and keep it elevated. We were on a camping trip at the beach when it happened and I don't remember it impeding much. I was dying to play after two or three weeks and just didn't use that finger until I couldn't resist anymore. There were no long term effects on my playing.
Posted on March 18, 2007 at 09:56 PM
From Ray RandallWhen you can, and with a Doctor's permission, get a light dumbell and rest your wrists on your knees while sitting down. Put your 3rd and 4th fingers of each hand under the flange of the dumbell and using only your fingers lift the weight up and down. You can isolate just the last joint and/or the joint near the palm. I now have a 4th finger to kill for.
Posted on March 18, 2007 at 11:14 PM
From al kuhello karen, i assume you are talking about the distal phalange, the one segment near the nail bed,,,
Posted on March 20, 2007 at 10:19 AM
one potential concern is that of muscle atrophy due to the lack of use while in splint. (not sure about your pinkie muscle condition, but a study done in the past showed that if you pay starving med students to lie still in bed for a week, they lose about 1-2% of strength PER DAY.) thus, to be properly reconditioned or conditioned during this recovery phase is important for injury prevention once you get back into your routine,,hard and fast.
i would consult with an occupational therapist (thus hand therapist), and NOT physical therapist (who is not really trained for hand as much as occupational therapist and the latter has nothing to do with helping one with getting a job:)
voice your concern as a musician early and ask for a taylored program to MAINTAIN some level of muscle use while in splint.
as tolerated (pain wise, i would assume couple weeks) start some isometric exercises while in splint (the OT can show you). then progress from there. once your fracture is diagnosed and properly evaled, your best friend is the occupational therapist.
the whole ordeal should take less than 3 months assuming the fracture is simple like a chip off.
in the foreseeable future, try leaving the lawnmower repair to the boys,,,
ps. i was in your beautiful state over the weekend...wintergreen,,,a blast.
From Keuna ChoWhen I was 11, I got a hairline fracture on my left pinky. It was in a splint for a month or two, but after that it was as good as new.
Posted on March 20, 2007 at 04:57 PM
From Dana BeattieThere's a book written by Carl Flesch called "Urstudien" that is intensive left hand training. One of my old teachers turned me on to it; he had broken a hand severely back in his days in Detroit. I use it as silent warm-ups to keep the dexterity of my fingers, and have loaned it out to others who now adore it. You should look into it.
Posted on March 20, 2007 at 08:07 PM
From Albert JusticeOne week just over two years ago I bought a beginner's violin set. That week I arranged lessons with an instructor. The following week and before my first lesson I fell and injured my left f2, f3, and f4 (f3 was worst) pretty severely. It took me about a year to get past the pain when playing, and my f3 is still not as confident as it could be, but makes tiny improvments monthly.
Posted on March 20, 2007 at 09:51 PM
So it really all depends on the injury. I did 'a lot' of manual strength training and dexterity training the first six months, and now just do Sevcik and other 4th finger exercises faithfully.
On the bright side, that focus on my left hand for so long will one day benefit me. Already it allows me to understand more complex discussions of southpaw technique if not really excel at them yet.
From jennifer steinfeldt warrenI'm not sure I understand the dumbell exercise. Wouldn't that be a bit risky? That position of the hand (wrist down pulling fingers up) is already an uncomfortable one if you are isolating single fingers. Maybe try doing that with the hand upright and without weights and you get the same effect, but without so much risk?
Posted on March 21, 2007 at 04:04 PM
But I might not know what you were talking about :)
From Erin DanielWhen I was 13 my sister broke my 3rd finger by slamming a door on it. I think it was an accident! Anyway, I had the same experience as Keuna, I was in a splint for about a month and then it was fine. I did practice piano (without the broken finger) though during that time.
Posted on March 22, 2007 at 02:50 AM
From Anne Oeldorf-HirschYears ago I smashed my right pinkie and never went to the doctor. Kept it in a splint till I thought it felt better and moved on. But I later realized that it had broken and now the joint is arthritic and can no longer be "fixed." To this day I still have a bit of trouble holding my bow comfortably anymore. I guess as long as you make sure it heals probably it should be fine. Don't do what I did!
Posted on March 22, 2007 at 03:58 AM
From Gabriel KastelleMany of the stories here are about childhood injuries. Healing is a very different thing with age. Also, completely variable depending on the unique character of your injury, so what can we say? Our different experiences can only help you balance factors and concerns in your judgments about timing and procedures and expenses of all kinds. On average, fingers can and do take incredible beatings and treatment in everyone's life, but they do fine. You say "minor", and I bet you'll be completely fine in a month or two, maybe just a little twinge now and again to remind you. Still, take care of fingers, and best of luck!!
Posted on March 22, 2007 at 05:23 AM
I received about four years ago, in my mid-thirties, a small avulsion fracture (ligament ripping a chunk of bone off its end at a joint) at the middle knuckle of my third finger of bow hand. It was of course the night before opening night of a musical directed by Julie Andrews (in her directorial debut). Valiant Viking violinist that I am (actually, poor and needy and unwilling to forego the work for any reason), I carried on with the month of the show. That was fine. Playing violin was the most comfortable, painless thing I did during any day for months! Besides the uniqueness of injury, I was subject to an astonishing host of aggravating circumstances before, during, and for at least months after the injury,
If you look up info on avulsion fractures, 90+% heal with no loss of function. I'm in the unlucky 10% or so, with finger unable to straighten by about 30 degrees (!!) even to this day, and apparently til death. I can almost curl it all the way. I've been interested to see over a long time, the first year or year and a half, the base knuckle gain compensating flexibility compared with the other fingers, so that mostly the fingers line up together anyway and make a hand. ANY other finger, and it would have been I think a career-ending disaster and/or grueling debt for very dubious surgical interventions.
Ring finger of bow hand is, I think, the most passive of a violinist's fingers. My life now is a unique accidental experiment looking into this idea. As it is, I was conscious for the better part of a year or so of slightly adjusting angles and balance in my right hand (and wrist and arm) and of actually re-learning to some extent all colle and spiccato and sautille in some tempi and characters, but I feel successful at that, really don't notice anymore, play fine, won audition into contract with minor local orchestra, type fine, etc..., all since the injury.
It took longer for my psyche to heal, in a way: I spent so long (even just a couple months forced into acting weird can be rough on my introverted self!) unable to shake hands in greeting or meeting, and felt SO BAD or ashamed, even though I knew I shouldn't feel that way, just at being a violinist with a broken finger.... It was surprising to me how much of our violinistic beauty is visual in the fingers! I felt probably worst meeting new students. Also, I'm one of those who talk with my hands-- very gestural communication. I had a very hard time for a while communicating or being with people, just unable to endure seeing the twisted finger in front of my face. Perhaps I still keep it out of sight (and out of harm's way!) a little more than I would without the break-- again, even though I don't believe I should behave that way. Interesting learning experience about the primal, visceral, central relation I have with myself and with others through the function and appearance of my fingers...
From Bilbo Prattle
Posted on March 22, 2007 at 10:45 PM
From Bill PlattBTW for the rest of you, I've watched Gabriel at close range, playing all sorts of beautiful stuff (including making my real gut setup sound really beautiful) and I never noticed. (He never told this story, either.) He compensates for the injury very well!
Posted on March 22, 2007 at 10:46 PM
From Gabriel Kastelle"(He never told this story, either.)"
Posted on March 23, 2007 at 04:40 AM
Well-- I'm not earning karma or getting paid to tell stories, but to teach your kids violin! Just trying to do what I should! Lessons are so dang short!
And, really, you're right: I was very prolix last night on at least a couple threads, but I think it's true that I've never told the story-- in print or in person anywhere so thoroughly before. Related to the general insecurity, fear, mis-placed shame I've felt over the finger.
Very kind words-- thank you, Bill. And also same thanks for your partly similar comments in other discussion threads lately, which I only found so late that a reply seemed too distant and out-of-place-- but I saw: thanks.
And, lest we be accused of hijacking the thread, let's recall that all of this verbiage is testimony and encouragement, and a result of sympathy and best hopes and wishes for the health and healing of everyone's fingers, especially Karen Johnson's.
See, Karen? Healing! :-) I'm really the only one who knows, and I forget often enough now, and my extenuating and exacerbating circumstances were outrageous and irreproducible (untold stories!), and I still bet you'll be completely fine soon!! :-)
From Ray RandallDoesn't hurt at all. Rest your wrists on your knees while sitting down. Lift a dumbell up and down with your fingers only, specifically in my case, the fourth and third fingers. Fingers under the flange of the weight. As of yesterday I'm up to 12 pounds and my fourth finger works so much better now.
Posted on March 24, 2007 at 01:06 AM
From Robert BerentzAre you taking Vitamin A and Calcium? It makes German Sheppard ears go up and all bones heal.
Posted on March 24, 2007 at 01:54 AM
From Gabriel KastelleVitamin D, do you mean? Vitamin D (a Vitamin D metabolite, actually)increases active transport from the intestines of calcium and phosphate.
Posted on March 24, 2007 at 06:53 AM
And, oddly overlooked by most, bones are great collagen network repositories of both calcium AND phosphate salts-- all the calcium in the world won't help a bone without a similar bulk of phosphorus / phosphates. Need both.
From Debbie Persselin
Posted on January 5, 2009 at 03:34 AM
Hello, I just joined. First I wanted to say that it's great to be here with so many other violinists.:) I've played since I was a child and I'm now in my 50's. Recently, I had what turned out to be a serious injury to my left hand.
In October of 2007, I tripped as I was crossing the street and sustained an intraarticular (the break crossed the joint line) displaced fracture to the top joint of my left ring finger. The first doctor put a pin in to hold the joint in place while it healed but the pin fell out. I was referred to a hand specialist who performed surgery on the joint to put it back in place. The surgery also involved remobilizing my extensor tendon on my middle joint as well as freeing the tendons on the top joint that had become embedded in the scar tissue.
Since the surgery was done 4 weeks after the fracture, it was impossible to reconstruct the original anatomy but the doctor told me it was very successful and everything looked good. The splints were removed on December 22nd and I began hand therapy on the 31st. The therapist has told me that since the fracture crossed the joint line, I will not be able to regain full motion in that joint, probably less than 50%, possibly only 30%. Right now I can barely move it. Both joints are very stiff from being immobilized for so long. However, she said I should be able to get closer to normal mobility on the middle joint.
As you can imagine, I'm pretty worried about how this will affect my playing or if I will even be able to come close to playing again with the skill I once had. I won't know what the final recovery will be until I complete 3 months of hand therapy. I was wondering if anyone here has ever had a similary injury and how it worked out for you. Any suggestions, help or encouragement would be very much appreciated! Thanks!
From Jim Tsai
Posted on January 5, 2009 at 06:10 PM
i suffered a fracture to my right middle finger in late August from a bike accident. It was an avusion fracture involving the dorsum of the distal phalanx, with intraarticular extension. i had it in a splint (constantly) for 11 weeks and the fracture still has not fully healed. Now there's no pain but i'm still working on getting full mobility. I probably won't be able to fully straighten the finger but i should be able flex the finger reasonably well after more therapy. i feel lucky because i can still hold a bow and manage to play, and even perform. I think it would be quite different if it were my left hand.
I just wanted to make several comments, as a medical professional. 1. kids heal much much better than adults when it comes to fractures. 2. intra-articular fractures (those that extend into the joint surface of the bone) are worse than fractures through the main body of the bone. 3. There are almost always accompanying non-bony injuries you need to pay attention to as well (tendons and ligaments). 4. Work with an orthopedic or plastic surgeon who specializes in hands and with a good therapist who also specializes in hand injuries. 5. Believe in the power of the body to heal. it may just take a little longer than you expect.
From Anne-Marie Proulx
Posted on January 6, 2009 at 01:27 AM
Do you want the hard truth or lies?
Ok, I'm honest so I will tell you my real story. I fractured my right pinkie while playing compulsory basketball at school. I had a cast on because I said to the doctor that I was a little afraid since my hobby was music and he did the most efficient thing. After, I went in physiotherapy and it never was the same finger despite all the recovery care and exercises. It defenitively could't trill fast ennough, the reflexes are slower and for bowing, it is find but if it was the left pinky and I was a pro I wouldn't be able to play. But, I think teaching would be very possible. It is hard to tell.
THIS IS ONLY MY EXPERIENCE AND I WISH VERY VERY MUCH THAT YOU WILL BE LUCKIER THEN ME!
GOOD LUCK AND ALL THE BEST!
From Debbie Persselin
Posted on January 6, 2009 at 04:49 AM
Thanks for your response and for your honesty. I'm trying to be positive but also realistic so I know it will never be the same again, just hoping I'll at least be able to play a little. Only time will tell. I'm pretty sure if I were a pro, my career would be over but I used to teach kids so that's something I can think about doing again some day to fill the void...Debbie
From Debbie Persselin
Posted on February 6, 2009 at 05:55 AM
Hi, just an update. After 6 weeks of physical therapy, I'm playing again. It's going pretty well, the lack of motion in the top joint isn't affecting my playing too seriously. It's still sore and stiff, I'll be continuing hand therapy twice a week for at least a couple more months but I'm able to play for about a half hour without much pain. It took a few days of playing scales and getting my finger accustomed to moving on the strings again. My tone and intonation have not suffered to any great extent except that I need a lot of practice after not playing for so long. Considering, I thought I might never be able to play again, I'm extremely happy with my progress so far. I was able to play the Bach Celebrated Air on the G string without too much trouble this evening so it's coming along.
From Richard Tracy
Posted on February 9, 2009 at 06:22 PM
The best therapy for finger injuries that I have found is an old manual typewriter. If you type properly, it forces the use of all the small muscles of the fingers and helps develop/tone them. It is painful at first, but it helped me quickly regain almost full use of the injured fingers.
From Robert English
Posted on March 20, 2009 at 06:55 PM
Stephane Grappelli suffered a fall in his Paris apartment, breaking the pinkie of his left hand.
Doctors pinned the break and when he recovered, he said his fourth finger was "better than new".
This is not an endorsement of broken fingers. Your mileage may vary.
From SAM MIHAILOFF
Posted on March 20, 2009 at 07:47 PM
You are a professional violinist...
Go see a performance arts doctor...don't just trust time to heal it.
IT IS YOUR LIVELIHOOD
From Gabriel Kastelle
Posted on September 17, 2009 at 04:13 PM
hmm... I was just thinking of the Stephane Grappelli experience. Since my earlier responses on this thread years ago (my finger still stuck at the thirty+ degrees), I've seen a double DVD biography film of Grappelli with interviews and playing.... maybe because of the wide cultural esteem for the value of his hands and playing, or for some medical reason I don't know, it was, he said, a gold pin that was put into his right pinkie. This gold pin stayed in, never came out, and Grappelli actually said that he believed it was faster and better than before. !!!! Not to recommend injuries and gold implants, nor to recommend how his colleague Django Reinhardt lost use of two fingers of left hand in fire, but these are pretty interesting, astonishing true stories about frikkin' amazing musicians carrying on inspiringly well through outrageous circumstances...
From Laura Gregg
Posted on October 26, 2011 at 11:07 PM
I posted this past June about my fractured left pinky. It was a "simple break" near the knuckle with a small floating chip. The x-ray was first read by the physician on-call, and then he sent it to a hand specialist when I informed him I was a violinist (playing 35 years). It was splinted for three weeks, and was told to start using it at the end of the third week. I was satisfied with the medical care, and when the finger was declared healed at week 6, I started playing long and hard as I had lost time to make up; I had an audition the end of August. In response to the practice, my finger went into contraction- it wouldn't even open- after it was supposedly healed. In contrast to the most recent post, playing soon after the break and playing aggressively aggravated the injury. In August I started OT therapy, but my finger didn't respond to the therapy. Finally in September I was seen at the Crystal Clinic (well known in my area as the best hand care facility around) and was told my recovery would have been better if I had gotten treatment and the subsequant follow-up care from a specialist immediately. So here is the lesson: if your hands are your livelihood (or very important to you) seek the very best treatment as soon as possible. Last Friday, Oct. 21st, my finger was finally straight after months of therapy and stretching devices. Now it has to be casted for four weeks. After the cast is removed it will be a slow (their instructions) recovery to playing my instrument again. My hope is that I will play again next season.
Our interview with Joshua Bell is one of more than two dozen in The Violinist.com Interviews: Volume 1, which also features talks with Sarah Chang, Maxim Vengerov, and David Garrett, as well as a foreword by Hilary Hahn.
Here's our daily coverage of the ninth quadrennial international violin competition, won by South Korea's Jinjoo Cho.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!