From Paul Reverter
Posted February 27, 2007 at 12:56 AM
David pretty well sums up his reputation. He and Moennig parted company, I think, about 5 years ago. I have a feeling that the Moennig who was running things then (I think it was W. Moennig III, father of a star of the "The L Word", who is now deceased) was not the easiest person in the world to work for.
He is very active in the VSA and other such organizations and I believe was recently asked by Curtis to give some classes on violins.
I've not seen him name much on attributions/certificates, etc. Perhaps that is changing. Others more up on this sort of thing than I may be able to shed some light on this.
I suspected that you were talking about Machold's relationship to this NJ Symphony business. But the article you reference is old news. Unless there has been something recently, my understanding is that Machold is doing business as usual. About the only interesting thing I am aware of is that Machold closed its NYC location and opened one in Chicago (same building as Bein and Fushi) a year or two ago. One of the people who worked in the NY office posts here sometimes. Maybe he can shed light on that. The rumor (and it is very much that) was that the move was strictly a business decision.
As for Mr. Hersh, I have never talked with him, but do know that he markets himself as kind of a consultant to buyers and sellers -- someone for you to hire if you want expertise in this rather opaque business. His reputation is good. At one time, Joseph Silverstein's son, Mark, worked for him. That may still be the case. I have no idea what he charges for his services or even how he works.
Here are some of the articles such as the Bisiach family which I have posted before in discussion:
or find it here:
The Bisiach Family
The Modern Neopolitan School
ps: on a personal note, Phil Kass along with J. Holmes, have been instrumental
in my becoming a member of the Appraisers Association of America.
Baese, Geary: Classic Italian Violin Varnish Vol 9 #2, p. 203-4
Comas, Ramon Pinto: Los Luthiers Espanoles Vol 10 #3, p. 169-173
Hamma, Walter: The Violin Makers of the German School Vol 9 #2, p. 201-2
Moschella, Ciro: Liuteria Italiana Moderna dall’Ottocento
al Novecento Vol 10 #3, p. 169-173
Regazzi, Roberto: The Manuscript on Violin Making by Giovanni
Antonio Marchi Vol 9 #2, p. 202-3
Stradivari e la Liuteria Cremonese dall’USSR Vol.10 #3, p. 169-173
Yokoyama, Shinichi: Three books on the Great Collections of
Washington DC Vol 8 #2, p. 152-4
In memoriam: Albert J. Kaplan Vol 6 #3, p. 109-12
In memoriam: Mark Reindorf Vol 13 #2, p. 229-31
On Society meetings
Exhibition of pre-1900 American Stringed Instruments
(part of 1976 Convention/Competition) Vol 2 #4, p. 70-83
Report on the Regional Meeting of the Society Vol 5 #2, p.76
On Instrument and Bow Makers
The Stati d’Anime of San Faustino in Cremona:
Tracing the Amati Family 1641-1686 Vol 12 #1, p. 3-85
Commentary on the instruments of the Bergonzi family and
Storioni (incorporated within Duane Rosengard’s article on
the later Cremonese makers) Vol 12 #1, p. 112-45
Stringed Instruments of the Milanese Liutai of the
Contrada Larga Vol 14 #3, p. 43-102
French Bows of the 19th Century
The Gemunder Family of Violin Makers Vol 6 #3, p. 36-58
(Speech at Music Mountain Convention 1982)
19th Century English Bowmakers of the Dodd & Tubbs Families Vol 10 #3, p. 99-139
(Speech at Oberlin Convention 1989)
The Violin Trade in 1992: An Economic Overview
(Speech at Carlisle Convention/Competition 1992) Vol 13 #1, p. 137-54
Modern Historical Research: The Violin as Art
(Speech at Connecticut joint meeting 1993) Vol 13 #2, p. 11-32
Bow Making and Microphotography
(Speech at Columbus Convention 1993) Vol 13 #3, p. 169-96
The Pressenda Family
(Speech at Boiling Springs Convention 1995) Vol 15 #1, p. 45-100
Nicolo Amati: His Life and Times
(Speech at Albuquerque Convention/Competition 1996) Vol 15 #2, p. 139-98
Violin Making in Turin 1800-1870
(Speech at Cincinnati Convention/Competition 2000) Vol 17 #3, p. 27-56
Panel Discussion on the Messiah Stradivari
(at Cincinnati Convention/Competition 2000) Vol 17 #3, p. 181-222
Philip J. Kass
Expert and Author on Fine Stringed Instruments and Bows
25 Year Associate of William Moennig & Sons, Ltd.
Appraisals and Certification
Member, Appraisers Association of America
By the way, at Robert Bein's memorial service yesterday, Charles Beare rated Robert as one of the top six experts of all time--something that many lower level violinists never caught onto during his life, I think.
As to your statement, I believe Phil may be both.
I wonder what you think about Duane Rosengard - member of The Philadelphia Orchestra since 1986 (Double Bass section).
Mr. Rosengard’s hobbies include the study of stringed instruments and their makers; and, since 1985, he has devoted much of his spare time to the study of Italian double basses from the 16th to 20th centuries. The results of Mr. Rosengard’s research have been published in journals and magazines in Italy, England, and the United States.
His most recent book is a biography of 18th-century Italian violinmaker Giovanni Battista Guadagnini, entitled Giovanni Battista Guadagnini: The Life and Achievement of a Master Maker of Violins, which was published in 2000. He is also the author of Contrabbassi cremonesi – Cremonese double basses, which appeared in an Italian-English edition in 1992.
Your ideas on this topic of expertise, which we've discussed before, are amusing for their unconventionality, but unfortunately they don't reflect any reality out there in the real violin world.
I leave for you the last word, which you will surely require, as usual . . . .
(I guess you missed my point as far as: "many lower level violinists never caught onto during his life").
As far as P.J.K., I must disagree with you. I also see that others disagree with you including David Russel.
But you are welcome to your opinion.
When Fritz Reuter was asked if he thought there was an appraiser in the world that had both the expertise and ethics to fairly and accurately authenticate and appraise the Axelrod collection now owned by the NJSO, the only name Fritz said came to mind was Phillip Kass.
ps:I'd like to hear your opinion of Charles Beare.
Violinist.com Editor Laurie Niles is in New York to cover the biennial event at The Juilliard School, including classes by Brian Lewis and Sarah Chang.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!