Why does my E string squeak?Instruments: This happens mostly when I am doing the string crossings in Bach's Prelude in E. Does anybody know why this is happening to me?
From Lisa Sailer
From Michael DarntonThe most likely answer is an improperly cut or adjusted post, or, less often, a faulty groove in the nut. Using a wound E string often cures the symptom without solving the underlying problem--something I don't encourage, because a poorly-fit post can damage the instrument.
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 02:34 AM
From Anita J.it happened to me too.my teacher said that sometimes it's because my bow is not straight. and when i checked my bow WAS not straight... so there's another possibility.
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 02:50 AM
From Eric SpritzerAlso make sure you are not touching the e string with the side of your fingers while you are reaching for notes on the a and d. That happens to me if my left wrist gets lazy. If I push my wrist out towards the scroll and try to approach the fingerboard more vertically with my fingers, there is less chance that I will accidently touch the e and cause a false harmonic type squeek.
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 12:46 PM
From David BurgessContinuing with Eric's theme, try fingering the A normally without playing, and notice if any of your fingers are also touching the E.
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 12:57 PM
If any of the fingers used to stop the A string are in light contact with the E when you make the string crossing, it will be much more likely to squeak, almost as if you were playing a harmonic.
You could try rolling the finger away from the E before the string crossing, as if you were going to use the open E in a double stop.
Experimenting with bow speed, pressure and contact point can help. A fast light bow will exacerbate the problem.
You could also try the "Kaplan solutions" non-whistling E, which was designed to help with this problem.
From Jay AzneerMake sure your frog is pulled in, ie closer to the bridge, for the string crossing
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 07:24 PM
From Daniel BroniatowskiIt might depend on the kind of string, although this isn't usually my experience. When this happens, it's usually because the E string is much thinner or lower than the other strings. The string is not able to take the same kind of angle that the other strings can take. Sometimes the E string needs more or less pressure/weight. To avoid the squeaks, I either have to sink in more weight or move the bow closer to the bridge.
Posted on January 1, 2007 at 08:16 PM
From Enosh KoflerHere is what I've found makes a difference:
Posted on January 2, 2007 at 04:03 AM
My soundpost was recently adjusted and it squeaks less.
Use a lot of rosin.
Angle the bow a little in and closer to the bridge.
From Andrew KoenigI recently found that cleaning the rosin residue off the string made a big difference.
Posted on January 2, 2007 at 05:38 AM
From Mike HuttonApart from the above suggestions, you may want to revisit your bow technique. I have found that a squeaking string (usually E) is down to a lack of pressure and thereby contact on the bow after you make the transition. an oblique (nonstraight) bow doesn't help here, but the problem is primarily one of contact.
Posted on January 8, 2007 at 12:38 PM
If the transition is a quick one (which it is in this case) the tendency can be not to fully contact the string and so you skim the string rather than actually play it. The way round I found was to use a slower bow stroke with more pressure.
The problem is easy to reproduce - just do really fast A-E transitions with a light bow stroke. If you play with an angled bow stroke you further reduce the contact between hair and string, and skimming becomes even more likely. Slow the bow and add more pressure, possibly by playing closer to the frog, and you'll be able to work out how to eliminate the squeak.
Hope this helps.
From Vince V.Yup... I was going to say that...
Posted on January 8, 2007 at 06:50 PM
Because the E string is always tightly wound, it tends to play a harmonic note when "activated" so next time, just add a little pressure -- if it doesn't respond to that, then get a new E.
It's a right hand technique thing.
From Elaine FineI got a Kaplan E-string in the mail today, and to my horror it had a ball end, and my violin has a tuner that takes a loop end. The Kaplan string came with a converter--a little ball-end holder that hooks onto the loop end holder. I tried it, and I didn't notice any squeaking, but I did notice a rattle. I tried to remove the ball (I usually can do that with most strings), and the loop came undone. Oh well. I'd rather squeak than rattle. I wonder if the ball end thing has something to do with eliminating the E-squeak?
Posted on January 9, 2007 at 01:10 AM
From stefanie landmannI doubt it has something to do with the ball. I use those e-strings and they still squeak sometimes. It's probably a better string that you got although I agree with the others - I think it's a right hand problem not so much a string problem.
Posted on January 10, 2007 at 05:45 PM
From Elaine FineI think I have figured out something about the squeaking E string. I think that it has to do with the wild resonance of the open E itself when it is in combination with other strings playing perfect intervals, both horizontally and vertically. Playing a double stop with a B on the A string and an open E always has the possibility of a squeak for me. I have to really use my right hand to stabilize the string in order for it not to squeak. A chord made of F#, B, and open E is a doozy: three stacked fourths carry a lot of overtone "baggage." Also an A major chord, played horizontally, as a slurred arpeggio, tends to squeak unless I am very careful with my right hand. Those are just thirds, but they are thirds that involve two resonant open strings.
Posted on January 12, 2007 at 05:09 PM
I also noticed that my open E will squeak more when the instrument is slightly out of tune or when the intervals I am trying to play are slightly out of tune. It is as if there is a fight between what the E should sound like in relation to the other notes and what it does sound like. The pitch gets thrust up somewhere in the harmonic series, ending at the most stable possible squeak.
From LisaJo BorchersI like the comment about "skimming' the string. I think the squeaking occurs on the open E more than the fingered E string. If you are "skimming" without enough weight a harmonic will sound on any string really. I have found that the E can take a bit more pressure than we think.
Posted on January 12, 2007 at 05:23 PM
I also like the comment about "pull in the frog." I think that "point of contact" is really crucial during the change of bow.
From Dmitri Torchinskymy own experience suggests that using a gold e-string (e.g. oliv, infeld red)increases your chances of this distrurbing noise. so notwithstanding the fact that I love the tone of the golden olive E, I tend not to use it as it reminds me of playing russian rulette.
Posted on January 12, 2007 at 05:33 PM
From Oded KishonyThe physics of the whitling E string has to do with torsional rotation of the string. The Kaplan solutions string is designed not to twist (torsionally rotate) and the ball is essential to it's function. I've never seen anyone able to make the Kaplan Solutions non whitleing E string wistle. (I believe it's guaranteed not to whitle).
Posted on January 12, 2007 at 06:40 PM
The odds are that it was something else that was causing the ratteling on your instrument.
From Christian AbelDoes the gold plating somehow exacerbate the torsional rotation then? Curious since I just put one on not 20 minutes ago! The reports of gold E's squeeking more just made me go "uh oh".(But it sure is purdy and sounds really warm)
Posted on January 12, 2007 at 08:01 PM
Hear more from the world's top violinists in The Violinist.com Interviews: Volume 1, which includes our exclusive conversations with Joshua Bell, Sarah Chang, and David Garrett, and others, as well as a foreword by Hilary Hahn.
Smiling as he spoke, Steinhardt offered his suggestions with clarity and appeal, in language both efficient and richly meaningful.
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!