Welcome to Violinist.com! Log in, or join the community!
Violinist.com
Facebook Twitter Google+ Email Newsletter

Mendy Smith

Student Becomes Teacher ?

November 25, 2014 20:56

Last week I had my first ever violin lesson. Not as a student - but as a teacher. This was odd enough given that I'm not a trained teacher by any stretch of the imagination, but also by the fact that I'm a violist.

It started when my colleague saw me hauling my viola out to my car after work to head to my private lesson (as a student) and mentioned that he was trying to learn violin via YouTube videos. After some discussion, it became apparent that he was getting frustrated quickly with his inability to pull any sort of a good tone from his instrument. It turns out that he is playing on a a fractional sized viola strung as a violin (sigh), but it was better than his e-bay violin. So, I offered to bring in my real (and good quality violin) the next day and give him a mini-lesson to get him started after office hours in the break room.

The next day we snuck into the break room after the end of the work-day with various instruments in tow. It was a violin-lesson flash mob-like experience. At one point we were interrupted by a guy working late walking in and being completely surprised by what was going on inside that break room. We couldn't help but laugh, and then proceed on.

I showed him how to figure out how to hold the violin comfortably. The technique I showed him is one that is written about in Primrose's book that has worked well for me over the years. He's starting with no shoulder-rest, but I had him try some sponges. The guy is well over 6' tall, thin as a rail with a very long neck. The sponges made a world of difference in his comfort & overall posture.

I then showed him how to hold the bow by holding out his hand and letting it relax and then bringing the bow to his hand. It took a little work to get his fingers in the right spots, but he got the concept after a few attempts. We then put the two together on open strings alone with a martele stroke. As expected, his bowing was not straight and he skimmed the surface of the string, so I held onto his bow hand and pulled it straight for a few strokes. He had a marvelous AHA moment when he realized that pulling a straight bow was a outward motion, not pulling back with his whole arm. After a few more minutes he had another AHA moment when he realized that it was the weight of the arm and not a pressing down that made the best tone.

And finally we got to making notes other than open strings. His intonation is actually pretty darned good. He has a good ear and corrects his intonation without the need of fingerboard tapes. I showed him how to work with open strings to check his intonation no matter the note. He already had a very firm theoretical and practical understanding of the various intervals. His problem was mostly in a collapsed hand and a weird thing he did with his fingers (curling them up when not in active use). We worked on correcting the collapsed hand and finger curling habit.

We then discussed practice techniques such as practicing in front of a mirror and what to look for, watching the sound point while practicing open strings, using open strings for intonation, and the "click" method for sustaining the tone from frog to tip. Basic and simple things to remember and take home.

Afterwards, he pulled out his mandolin and blew my socks off with his "fiddle" tunes. In exchange, I pulled out Bach and introduced him to the world of the C-string and let him give my viola a try.

At the end of the day, he went home excited to try out the practice techniques I showed him. We will do it again in a few weeks, and next time he promised to give me an intro to mandolin lesson. With any luck, a few of these "lessons" will get him past the initial frustration and into lessons with a "real" violin teacher. In the meantime, we have a really cool way to end a work day every once in awhile and get some "team-building" in while we are at it.


4 replies

Music Therapy

November 14, 2014 18:49

Last month I blogged about how Music Matters . Since that blog, my teacher and I have worked closely together to develop a plan that makes the best use of what time I have available to practice until the project I'm running is completed. We've shelved new pieces and etudes and pared down what is on my stand to a well known etude and piece. The key is "no new notes".

The etude is Kreutzer #2 (I can play the notes from memory) with the focus on bowing. Every other week a new pairing of bowing techniques are introduced such as detache and staccato - changing bowing technique every other measure. It is simple enough to spend several minutes each day completely focused on just one thing - my right arm - no worries about anything else, just the right arm. In a surprisingly short period of time, my tone has become much more focused and controlled than before, and more delightedly my intonation improved (as my teacher said it would).

The piece is one from my Bach By 40 goal. Suite 5 is getting dusted off and polished up. Again, no new notes, but now I'm studying it again with a different perspective with the tools in my "musical tool box" I've gathered since I first started studying the suites many years ago. Week after week I've been having several "AHA" moments. Techniques that were in their early stages of development back then are now more easily executed in context. Vague understandings of some aspects of music theory are now making intuitive musical sense. But most importantly, my Bach playing has taken leaps and bounds. It is a complete joy to play. I can lose myself for hours exploring intricacies in Bach that I wasn't able to appreciate four years ago.

Rather than skimming the surface of many skills that need development week over week, my teacher and I are delving deeper into a select few to refine and perfect them to the best of my ability. We both expect that when this project is over, I'll break out of the plateau I've been in months and take another musical leap.

Stay tuned. In a month or so, I may post a recording (or not).

1 reply

Previous entries: October 2014


The Violinist.com Interviews, Vol. 1

The Violinist.com Interviews, Vol. 1

Hear more from the world's top violinists in The Violinist.com Interviews: Volume 1, which includes our exclusive conversations with Joshua Bell, Sarah Chang, and David Garrett, and others, as well as a foreword by Hilary Hahn.

Get it now! For Kindle | For iBooks | In Paperback