Comments

I would take Ravel's string quartet in F major(not listed) What happened to Brahms? Kreisler´s String Quartet! I fell in love with this sweet and pleasant work. I will wait until IMSLP is resurrected. That way, I could play all the quartets in public domain...and then bring along the Bartok set!

Also, I want to be stranded with Arnold Steinhardt, Janos Starker, and Paul Neubauer. That should be a bit humbling...

If I were stranded on a desert island, my first priorities would be for survival. Therefore; water, shelter, food and warmth would come first.

Since paper is useful for many things, starting fires, for example, I'd choose the composer who wrote the most and longest compositions. ;)

Curious you don't list Brahms...or Cherubini for that matter....and why is it always a desert island ? How about a fertile,swampy or glacial island ? 'twould make a difference in choice of music and players. This really is a tough choice you know. The quartet literature is sooo rich . . . I want them all! After Beethoven, I'd totally pick Brahms. I love his chamber music . . . I voted for Beethoven, but thinking about the desert island survival aspect, a book of Schubert would probably kill two birds with one stone as he tends to write in big chunks that get transposed about six or seven times. It should be possible to rip out most of the pages to start a fire when necessary while still being able to play the music, just repeating one of those sections in the different keys. This would develop transposition skills at the same time... Beethoven Volume 3, no question. very close call between Beethoven and Haydn - especially if you get the complete works! But in the end, it has to be Beethoven. Mendelssohn for sure. Not even a doubt in my mind about that. There is always a new arrangement, new composer, ancient tunes rediscovered...this would be an impossible choice! I think I'd take my phat gig books. Right now I'm listening for the first time to string quartet arrangements of Chinese folk music by Shanghai Quartet 2nd Violinist on deezer.com -- force me to choose and it would probably be Puccini. Totally Bartok... It was a tie between Bartok and Beethoven. I don't think I'd be able to take Beethoven's seriousness all the time... so I chose bartok. Both awesome composers! Can't see your list for some strange reason, but today I'd got for Dvorak's American. Tomorrow I might feel differently :-) That's not a fair list !!!
Where's Brahms? My favorite string quartet players and I relish Brahms. You guys are all very welcome to bring the Brahms to the desert island, mea culpa! I would chose the Brahms, but for a second, Mozart as I can not ever get tired of his works. Beethoven - String quartet in c-minor op. 18 nr 4. That's really one of my favourite. Beethoven, hands down. What an amazing spectrum of styles (early, middle late)... he perfected the classical era, stretched limits in the middle period, and the late quartets are a daring look into the future. Mendelssohn... or Brahms... OMG I want all of them! Schubert hit the nail on the head when he commented about Beethoven's late quartets: "After this, what is there left to write for us?"

As for the desert scenario, considering that Haydn wrote 68 whilst Debussy and Ravel only wrote 1 quartet, perhaps you should be allowed to pick a collection of a certain number of quartets, ie 10, 20, 30 pieces. In that case my list would look something like this...

Bach "Art of Fugue"; Haydn "Erdody"; Mozart "Dissonance"; Beethoven "Rasumovsky", "Serioso" and all the "late" quartets; Schubert "Rosamunde", "Death & Maiden" and "Quartettsatz"; Brahms all; Dvorak "American"; Janacek both; Debussy and Ravel (one each); Bartok Nos. 3,4 and 5; Schostakovich Nos. 3, 8 and 11

Yet if I was forced to pick a single composer, then that would have to be Beethoven, without any hesitation.

I forgot Mendelssohn op.80 and 81 on that list though Something that's easy but sounds hard so the natives will think you're gods and not eat you. However wonderful other quartet composers were, there was only one in the frame if stuck on an island: Beethoven, for the late quartets. I'd take the Elgar quartet, even if Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven had each written 1000. It's not humanly possible to write a more beautiful piece.

After that, probably the Grieg Gm, because it's the most fun to play!

Of course, it's nice to fantasize in the abstract, but if I were really presented with this scenario I bet I'd grab my Beethoven cycle without a second thought.

Would be nice if I rescued a book with all or most of the composers listed and unlisted. Trios might be more use as when it comes down to the final nitty-gritty of survival, I'm afraid we'll have to sacrifice the viola for firewood...