Practice for Practice's Sake
February 11, 2013 at 5:55 PMI entered my music classroom on a Tuesday morning, after a three day weekend, and stared at a dozen violin cases in the corner. Since the school is always locked on weekends, I could reasonably assume that my students' instruments were not used for at least three days. After looking at the names on the cases, I realized that some students never picked up their instruments from the week before! I was slightly annoyed because it seemed like they didn't care to practice. I was slightly embarrassed because these were MY students who didn't practice. But, I was mostly saddened because I knew my budding violinists were not going to reach their full potential with their current practice habits. Something needed to change.
My predecessor required one hundred fifty minutes of practice five times a week. Every student had to write their times down on a chart inside their book and have a parent sign it at the end of the week. So, when I started teaching at this school nearly a decade ago I expected the same. However, some students lied about the number of minutes practiced each week, and their parents were accomplices by signing the charts. Other students found the demands of the practice routine to be too much to handle and, rather than lie, they quit orchestra. Several of these honest musicians were my best performers!
I decided to break with tradition and not require practice charts at all. Besides, performance was what mattered most, and students who peform well are most likely to be practicing at home. I created an incentive system called Karate Orchestra, similar to Recorder Karate used by many general music teachers across the US. Students earn belts (colored electrical tape) to place on their bows after passing performance tests of increasing difficulty. Motivation for practicing soared as long as there was a belt test to pass, but it was impractical to test weekly on everything that students must learn. I also noticed that many still didn't know how to practice, even for a test. My students need me to teach them how to practice at home.
Music Educators Journal published Hannah Smeltz's article, "Reframing Student Practice to Facilitate Lifelong, Joyful Musicianship," in December 2012. I read this article at the same time that I was searching for ideas to help my students practice at home, and the timing of the publication was just as perfect as the relevant information I obtained from it. Ms. Smeltz said that students who use practice charts focus on time and those who take playing tests focus on grades. She believes that, in order for students to become lifelong musicians, they must practice for practice's sake. She encouraged her readers to show students how enjoyable practicing at home can be by setting goals and using a variety of practice strategies. In addition, students should be free to practice non-lesson material, improvise, compose, and listen to high quailty performers as part of their overall practice regimen.
The day I read this article I became determined to change how my students practice at home. I created a weekly journal to help guide them. The first part of the journal is a place for students to write down their goals for the week. These goals are measureable achievements, usually related to a particular week's lesson. The second part of the journal is the daily practice portion, where students write down what they practiced, practice strategies used, what went well, and what still needs to be improved. My students do need a parent signature, and they do receive a grade for completing their journal, but the emphasis is not on the amount of time spent on practicing, but rather the process of improving a particular skill or piece of music. I spend a considerable amount of time during lessons explaining and demonstrating a variety of practice strategies to use for skills or passages that must be mastered. My students even have a strategy sheet in their music folder that they can refer to when practicing at home. I look through their journals each week and make suggestions where appropriate. I also encourage them to play songs for fun, write their own music, and listen to their favorite orchestra musicians. I should also mention that I have been journaling my own practice routine with my students, who have held me accountable to practice at home too.
As I'm writing this blog post, we are in our third week of journaling. It has already made a big difference. One parent thanked me in person, saying that the strategies sheet has helped her know how to help her son practice at home. My rehearsals are more productive because my students are already learning their orchestra music faster. And most importantly, I don't see a dozen violin cases in the corner anymore.
From Josh ReynaThat is awesome! I always kept some sort of journal with my lessons/practicing time, but it never occured to me to have students do the same. I had considered creating some sort of practicing time log for kids to check and parents to sign; but I know that many times this can cause more boxing matches at home. I've heard some horror stories of parents who can't get their kids to practice.
Posted on February 11, 2013 at 10:57 PM
I'm definitely going to try this journaling thing out.
From Nathan KroptavichThank you Josh. I think accountability with flexibility is important. That's why I think journals work better than practice charts. If you can encourage your students to find at least one thing to do each day, instead of giving them a set number of minutes to practice, you may find less of a struggle. Also, one strategy that may help your students on busy days is "mental practice." Students take their music out and read the music while playing "air-violin." Mostly everyone rides in the car somewhere and can spare a few minutes for this type of practice, which at least gets students thinking through their music. It's not a substitue for physical practice, but it works in a pinch on busy days.
Posted on February 12, 2013 at 2:16 AM
From Mendy SmithI have finally learned how to practice effectively, not more, and I've been playing for more years than I care to admit. The idiom "work smarter, not harder" is something that needs to be taught early on.
Posted on February 12, 2013 at 4:23 AM
From Nathan KroptavichI completely agree with you, Mendy. Focused practice is the key to improving, not length of time. By the way, I love your A-Z goal for 2013. Best wishes to you!
Posted on February 12, 2013 at 11:30 AM
From Anne-Marie ProulxMendy, how true...
Posted on February 12, 2013 at 1:20 PM
When I started, I used to play these Bach and vivaldi concertos + Wolfhart for hours and hours as a very desperate student. I remember getting up in the middle of the night to play when I already was tired and scraped many violin lessons out of tiredness. Overall, it did work but it took forever to make a bit of progress.
Now, with less time because of school and harder peices on my hands, it's just not possible to work that way and I got injured a few months ago by trying to hard the wrong way. Score reading, listening, reviewing notes of what my teacher said, using the metronome if needed and tricks I found myself is definitivly as important as playing and very efficient to save practicing time!
From Josh ReynaWhat does this practicing strategies sheet look like?
Posted on February 14, 2013 at 5:18 PM
From Nathan KroptavichIf you send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org, I would be happy to send you a copy of the practice strategies and journal.
Posted on February 15, 2013 at 5:57 PM
This entry has been archived and is no longer accepting comments.
Violinist.com Editor Laurie Niles went to Austin, Texas to cover the Menuhin Competition 2014, watching some of the world's top young violinists. Read her ongoing coverage.
Nathan Kroptavich is from Clarks Summit, Pennsylvania. Biography
Please consider supporting Violinist.com by becoming a sponsor, and reaching our dedicated community of violin professionals, students and fans!